Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Explaining Jeremy Lin's Early, Surprising Success

The Blue-Gray Sky Asks: "Hey man, have you seen Eric McClendon lately?"

One of the things we pride ourselves on here at Dawg Sports is our engagement in the larger Sports Blog World. I kid Kyle occasionally about being the John Barth of the sports blog world (because he is a master of blogging about blogging), but there is a kernel of admiration in that ribbing. We try to recognize the exceptional work done by other bloggers, and route you to other blogs which you'll find interesting, informative and downright entertaining. That's what sets the blogosphere apart from a lot of traditional media. Really, when was the last time somebody from the Washington Post encouraged you to head over to the New York Times sports page for a solid take on the Yankees? Yeah, that's my point.

One site that I frequently visit, and encourage you to check out is Notre Dame blog The Blue-Gray Sky. Pat at BGS is, for the third year in a row, breaking down past recruiting classes to determine which players lived up to expectations. In the process he isolates some interesting trends, and spotlights a veritable who's who of guys all recruitniks pined for in 2004 and couldn't pick out of a lineup now.

I won't go into Pat's proprietary system because it involves numbers, and numbers give me hives. Sorry. But he does use a sampling of recruiting service rankings to compile a composite "National Top 50". He's also generally kind to Georgia's 2004 signing class, labelling Charles Johnson and Thomas Brown success stories, while withholding judgment on Brandon Miller and noting that his pending status as a bust has something to do with high expectations from being the #6 overall recruit in the country coming out. He notes some trends which a lot of us probably recognized at a visceral level, but lacked any data to substantiate. For example:

Offensive linemen are hard to scout. You never know which ones are going to turn into Duke Robinson, and which ones will turn into James Lee. Especially if you happen to be named Neil Callaway. That makes it, like, double hard to tell. But I digress.

Tom Lemming is a shill, and even Domers know it. Pat gets extra points in my book by simply acknowledging that Tom Lemming's ranking of players interested in Notre Dame or originating in the state of Illinois are simply flat wrong, and declining to include Lemming's rankings in his composite. Well played, Pat. And finally,

The recruiting services ain't half bad. Pat notes that the number of top 50 guys who turn into solid all-conference level performers is pretty high, and that highly rated players are more likely to be knocked off track by bad grades, off-field mayhem and injury than on-field underperformance.

That's really just a thumbnail sketch though, you really should go read the whole article if you follow recruiting. And after that, go vote for Georgia swimmer (and Olympian) Kara Lynn Joyce for the ESPY in the category of best female college athlete. It's your duty as an American and as a citizen of Bulldog Nation. And if you're from Dodge County, you may even be able to find someone to pay you for it. I kid, I kid. Sorta. Until later . . .

Go Dawgs!!!

Comment 3 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Player Rankings
Good post from Blue-Gray Sky.  I thought he was a little generous with his rankings (re Willie Williams. IMHO, if you don't do anything for the school that first offered you, you are a bust.  Same story for Rhett Bomar).  CollegeFootballNews.com does something like for the last few years, and it usually shows that about a third of the top 100 are busts of one kind or another.  Ahh, recruiting.

by Bonkers on Jun 26, 2007 9:21 PM EDT reply actions  

Recruiting
I had suggested something like this, but a little different- tracking the top recruiting classes each year and comparing them with national titles- particularly 3 years after each class- to see if there is a true correlation between having good recruiting classes and winning national titles. Unfortunately, I haven't been a committed as BGS.

by fotodog on Jun 26, 2007 10:28 PM EDT reply actions  

thanks
Hey MaconDawg, thanks for the shout-out.  That's always a fun post to put together for us.

by Jay at BGS on Jun 27, 2007 11:27 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.

Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

017oa_small MaconDawg

Editors

Redstage_small DavetheDawg

Whistling_past_small NCT

434477_small vineyarddawg

Layfield_logo_small RedCrake

Hey-why-so-serious_small tankertoad

Podunkdawg_as_a_child_small podunkdawg

Dawggone_small Ludakit

Authors

28488_443996218101_804558101_5903592_3665419_n_small Spears

Small hailtogeorgia

Killface_small Mr. Sanchez

50questions-accountant_small The Quincy Carter of Accountants