Dawg Sports: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Kevin Duckworth, Dead, at 44 Bar-right-arrows



Can We All Agree? (Quick Hits Edition)

Since I am in the midst of a debate with Sunday Morning Quarterback over what may be the most divisive issue in college football, this seemed like an opportune time to trot out the latest edition of "Can We All Agree?"

Because so many thorny questions force conscientious college football fans into opposing camps, it is useful to examine some potential points of contention to identify red herrings, false dichotomies, and non-issues, thereby finding common ground in at least some areas of possible dispute.

In quick-hit fashion, therefore, I ask for unanimous consent upon the following matters, as to which it seems to me that no genuine controversy exists. Can we all agree . . .

. . . that a four-day suspension is no suspension at all? South Carolina recruit Stephen Garcia was suspended on Monday, but his punishment was lifted on Thursday. It seems Steve Spurrier has once again gone into the excuse-making business.

Pat Dye, on the other hand, thought Coach Spurrier came down way too hard on the young man, believing as he did that a two-day suspension would have sufficed.

. . . that the forces of political correctness have an opportunity to kill two birds with one stone? It'd be simple, really. They could just bury Chief Illiniwek somewhere in the area of Cal's stadium. You do not want to get me started on this silliness. . . .

. . . that even a bad show by Aaron Sorkin is better than a good show by most of the rest of the T.V. writers on the planet? O.K., "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip" isn't "The West Wing." It isn't even "Sports Night." I promise you it's better than anything else N.B.C. could line up to put in that time slot.

I knew the show was doomed when we lost Doug to "30 Rock" instead.

. . . that Jim Delany is the most hypocritical conference commissioner in intercollegiate athletics? First, he said the Big Ten wouldn't recruit athletes with S.E.C. speed because they're not academically qualified . . . even though the Big Ten and the S.E.C. went head-to-head in competition for numerous recruits and the S.E.C. isn't doing any worse by its players than the Big Ten (although these data are not without their detractors). Now, the longstanding bastion of amateurism and purity is looking at reshuffling the schedule to be more competitive. Not to pick on Michigan or anything, but let's not forget that the Wolverines were playing 12-game schedules as early as 1892 and 13-game schedules as early as 1905. The Maize and Blue also opened three straight seasons with double-headers, playing both Albion and Mt. Union on September 28, 1929, facing Denison and Eastern Michigan each on September 27, 1930, and defeating Central State Teachers College and Eastern Michigan back-to-back on October 3, 1931. The Big Ten needs to lose this pretense of moral superiority.

. . . that some misdeeds ought not to be punished too severely because the wrongdoer clearly was too stupid to have intended any harm? Reportedly, a Southern California hockey player dropped trou and mooned the crowd at a road game at B.Y.U., earning himself an ejection and a ticket for misdemeanor lewdness in the process. Having had to defend something similarly stupid a year ago, I can sympathize with Trojan fans' embarrassment, but, in the kid's defense, it's a pretty good bet that the definition of public lewdness is a whole lot harsher in Utah than it is in Los Angeles.

. . . that it'd be really cool if some bowl matchups were arranged based upon the bloggers who cover the respective teams? Wouldn't it be great if Notre Dame and Southern Miss squared off in the postseason so that we could see The Blue-Gray Sky and Sunday Morning Quarterback bombard one another with dizzying statistical minutiae? Wouldn't you love to see a Michigan-U.C.L.A. Rose Bowl for the first time since the 1982 season just so Bruins Nation and MGoBlog could mix it up a little? Wouldn't a Louisville-Utah clash in a bowl game be made intriguing simply by virtue of Card Chronicle's and Block U's competing claims that each of theirs was the more undeservedly disrespected team?

Insert obligatory Rodney Dangerfield reference here.

Am I out on my own on those issues or can we come to a consensus on some of that? Talk to me, people!

Go 'Dawgs!

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Oddly enough, the Utes play Louisville this season
It's in Louisville, so I've already conceded a loss!

by JazzyUte on Feb 23, 2007 1:23 AM EST   0 recs

Disagree on Studio 60
I tried to like it, I really did...but I got tired of being preached at every week about how dumb we red-staters are, so I had to stop watching it.

Also, if you want to see really excellent writing and even better acting, check out Friday Night Lights, which absolutely is more deserving of the prime post-Heroes time slot.

by UPSDawg on Feb 23, 2007 8:06 AM EST   0 recs

Thanks for defending 'Studio 60'
I like that show. I didn't watch 'The West Wing,' but the point I've been making about 'Studio 60' is the same as yours: it's doomed by too-high expectations. '30 Rock' may actually be a little better (only a little), but 'Studio 60' is a perfectly decent show. I think Sorkin tries to reach out and show respect to 'red staters' (a description I hate, since it disregards the significant swatch of voters in my state, 40%, that voted for John Kerry) more than any other writer on TV, most of whom outside of 'South Park' ignore non-coastal locales completely. One of the central characters is the first regular, non-mocking depiction of a conservative Christian on one of the four major networks in probably decades. Sorkin doesn't get it right all the time, but he makes the effort. And the FCC storyline about the fine for a soldier's on-air expletive when a bomb goes off during an interview really interests me.

'Heroes' I tried to like but have found too ridiculous. Ali Larter is insufferable. I didn't even try to like 'Friday Night Lights,' which I found immediately ridiculous (players in real life do have devastating spinal injuries, but dramatically, it's a cheap movie-of-the-week ploy). The football scenes, typically, are jerky and melodramatic. The model for all on-screen football action should be 'All the Right Moves,' which actually looks like high school kids playing.

SMQ.

by smq on Feb 23, 2007 10:06 AM EST   0 recs

Friday Night Lights
Agree 100% with UPSDawg that trying to like "Studio 60" was just too damn hard.  Still, the pilot and the Christmas episode were great televion, with some other quality moments mixed in.  Too much preaching.

FNL is probably one of the top few shows on television right now, and I encourage anyone that enjoys quality television to check it out.  You have to accept the fact that majority of a team's games are going to come down to a trick play or perfectly-blocked screen, but it's good stuff.  If time becomes available, I'll write a treatise extolling its virtues and providing a catch up as the Dillon Panthers season rolls on.

http://www.rakesofmallow.com/

by CW on Feb 23, 2007 12:31 PM EST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Avatar_small
Fantasy Football (Public and Private), Pickem Leagues, Confidence pools, etc... Good site
Will_queen_photo_small
On Fathers, Sons, and College Football
Small
What's the Deal?
Millers_crossing
Mayor, you may have lost your title
Millers_crossing
Which of these teams will reemerge as national contenders?
100_0141_small
Marcus Howard is loved in the pro's
Small
Georgia bar in LA???
36413436t_small
ASU Tix in Hand; You East Coasters Will Have them Today or Tomorrow
Uga_small
Sturdivant Injured?  NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!
Uk_game_small
New Brass Recording of "Red and Black March"

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

ad

Site Meter