Dawg Sports: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Phillies trade for OF Matt Stairs Bar-right-arrows



Where Does Mark Richt Rank Among S.E.C. Coaches?

The offseason is a vast void stretching from a week after New Year's Day to the Thursday before Labor Day, which must be filled through such largely ephemeral exercises as ranking the S.E.C. coaches.

Orange and Blue Hue has done it. Paul Finebaum has done it. College Football Resource has done it.

All of them rank Nick Saban and Nancy Meyer ahead of Mark Richt.

I take nothing away from Coaches Meyer and Saban, but I have a hard time seeing the rationale behind putting either of them ahead of Coach Richt.

Ah, yes, Coach Richt has not yet---emphasis on the yet---won a national title, whereas the other two have. Were those coaches' national championship campaigns better than Coach Richt's best season, though? I don't think so.

In 2006, Coach Meyer's Florida Gators went 13-1, captured the S.E.C. championship, and won a B.C.S. bowl game over a major conference champion.

In 2003, Coach Saban's Louisiana State Tigers went 13-1, captured the S.E.C. championship, and won a B.C.S. bowl game over a major conference runner-up.

In 2002, Coach Richt's Georgia Bulldogs went 13-1, captured the S.E.C. championship, and won a B.C.S. bowl game over a major conference champion.

In 2006, the Gators' only loss was by 10 points. In 2003, the Bayou Bengals' only loss was by 12 points. In 2002, the Bulldogs' only loss was by seven points.

In 2006, the Gators won the S.E.C. championship game by 10 points. In 2003, the Bayou Bengals won the S.E.C. championship game by 21 points. In 2002, the 'Dawgs won the S.E.C. championship game by 27 points.

There are, of course, distinctions to be drawn between those three teams---for instance, the Ohio State team Florida faced in Glendale was significantly stronger than the Florida State team Georgia faced in New Orleans---and I in no way dispute the legitimacy of Florida's and L.S.U.'s claims to the national championship.

However, the primary difference between the '02 'Dawgs and the S.E.C. squads that subsequently won national championships is the luck of the draw. The Red and Black went 13-1 in an autumn in which two B.C.S. conference teams went into the bowl games with undefeated records. Had the Bulldogs' 13-1 S.E.C. championship campaign come in 2003 or in 2006, Coach Richt would have a national title; had the Tigers' or the Gators' similar seasons come instead in 2002, neither Coach Meyer nor Coach Saban would have hoisted the crystal football.

Once again, that is not to deny the legitimacy of Florida's achievement this year or L.S.U.'s achievement in 2003, nor is it to suggest that Georgia somehow was robbed of a chance to play for the national championship in 2002. It is merely to illustrate that, however different the spoils of victory may have been, Coach Richt's best season was the equal of Coach Saban's and Coach Meyer's respective best seasons.

Coach Richt has twice as many S.E.C. championships and thrice as many S.E.C. championship game appearances as Coach Meyer. Coach Richt has the same number of S.E.C. championships and twice as many 10-win seasons as Coach Saban. While arguments certainly may be mounted in favor of Coach Meyer and Coach Saban, the case for Coach Richt is equally strong and anyone who argues otherwise is selling something.

Go 'Dawgs!

0 recs | Comment 6 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Thought you might
I was gonna comment on all this, Kyle, but figured you'd get around to it.

I can't say I really understand the rationale behind placing Meyer ahead of Richt. Saban, either. If it's supposed to be a "power" ranking, as opposed to a "resume" analysis, I guess there's no point in arguing. Of course, if it were a subjective power ranking, I'd still rank Richt at the top of the list.

Can't say that I'd rather have any other coach in the SEC over Richt.

by HornsFan on Jan 21, 2007 3:19 PM EST   0 recs

That's the way I look at it
When push comes to shove, the question always comes down to this: "If you could trade Coach X for Coach Y, would you do it?"

There have been times when my answer would have been, "Yes." After Erk left for Statesboro, I would have traded Vince Dooley for Coach Russell. I would trade Willie Martinez for Brian VanGorder right now. I wouldn't trade Mark Richt for anyone.

There is no denying Urban Meyer's and Nick Saban's accomplishments, which I do not demean. However, Coach Saban has been out of the college game for two years and there is no assurance that he will bounce back from his N.F.L. experience any better than Steve Spurrier has.

As for Coach Meyer, well, he did in his second year at Florida what he did in his second year at Bowling Green and at Utah, taking his team one giant step forward. What does he do for an encore, though?

We don't know the answer to that question. There is no template for Coach Meyer in his third year. We know he can win with his predecessor's players; we don't know if he can win with his players. We also don't know how well the Gators can handle success. (After winning their last national title in 1996, the Orange and Blue went four years before winning their next S.E.C. championship and they made just two appearances in the Georgia Dome in the next nine years.)

Of the three, Coach Richt is the most proven commodity right now . . . and, honestly, if you had to put money on a particular coach still being employed at the same school five years from now, is there even the remotest chance anyone would bet on Urban Meyer or Nick Saban over Mark Richt?

by T Kyle King on Jan 21, 2007 5:32 PM EST   0 recs

Good Post, Mr. King
I'm glad that you brought up the above comment regarding Urban Meyer winning in year 2 at each of the programs he has been a head coach at.  This is the trend and we have no past evidence to show us that he can be successful for an extended period of time, similar to what Richt has done with the Dawgs.

However, a reason that we are all of a sudden seeing this Meyer hysteria (other than the NC, of course) is that he and his coaching staff is putting together yet another great recruiting class this season...after bringing in Tebow and Harvin last February.  If he can't win with the talent we are seeing in these classes.  The thing is, though, we just don't know.  A lot of coaching in college is developing these young men into winners.  Sure Harvin is good, and Tebow made an impact, but will they continually improve along with their teammates as Meyer coaches 'em through the years?

You're right, Mark Richt is the most proven head coach in the SEC right now.  Gator fans are well aware of his abilities - his offenses at FSU were always some of the best, and his 'Dawgs have continually seen success in the conference.  However, if Meyer can continue to recruit the caliber of athletes he has in the last two years to go along with winning ball games, the gap will be closed very quickly in my opinion.

by Mark on Jan 22, 2007 10:38 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

re: Coach Rankings
Despite the fantastic track record under Richt, do you get the feeling that there are a number of people who still don't consider UGA a "major" SEC power?  I think things like Coach Rankings may in part reflect this.  The 90s are over, though, and that's as true in Athens as it is anywhere.  

by peacedog on Jan 22, 2007 2:52 PM EST   0 recs

Fulmer gets too much hype
I think you're right peacedog. If you look at all of the SEC coaching rankings going around the blogs these days, they all have Phillip Fulmer ranked very high despite the fact he's struggled the past couple of years and that this year - their 'return to glory' year - netted the Volunteers the exact same record as Georgia's 'rebuilding' year.

I'd rank Richt, Saban and Meyer at the top of the heap, and an argument could be made they're interchangeable ... but you've got a big question mark surrounding Meyer's long-term success. I'm still not convinced he doesn't find something shinier a year or two down the road and head over there.

by Jmac on Jan 24, 2007 11:35 AM EST   0 recs

I agree he is #3 or even a #4
Both Saban and Meyer took programs to the Title quicker... and won.  Sure, Richt is a great coach.  But even his "best" year, we were not close to the best.  Let's all agree we beat a puny FSU team that year.  They started a WR at QB!  

Richt is doing a great job, but lets face it... Meyer did more with less.  Cant forget Tuberville either.  We all know (no matter how much we hate Auburn)... AU was robbed that year.  That is THREE "titles" to our 0.  We havent even played in the BIG game.

by ssidedawg1 on Jan 24, 2007 10:30 PM EST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Images_small
Behold Uga VII!
Avatar_small
Fantasy Football (Public and Private), Pickem Leagues, Confidence pools, etc... Good site
Will_queen_photo_small
On Fathers, Sons, and College Football
Small
What's the Deal?
Millers_crossing
Mayor, you may have lost your title
Millers_crossing
Which of these teams will reemerge as national contenders?
100_0141_small
Marcus Howard is loved in the pro's
Small
Georgia bar in LA???
36413436t_small
ASU Tix in Hand; You East Coasters Will Have them Today or Tomorrow
Uga_small
Sturdivant Injured?  NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

ad

Site Meter