Dawg Sports: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Phillies trade for OF Matt Stairs Bar-right-arrows



Is There a Big 12 Bias?

Recently, I shot back in the latest exchange of fire between the Pac-10 and the S.E.C. . . . but I find myself wondering whether West Coast fans are fighting the wrong enemy.

Don't worry; I'm not going to let any crazy bald female singers rip up photographs of world religious leaders here at Dawg Sports. (Image from Amazon.com.)

Ted Miller---yes, that Ted Miller---recently quoted Oregon coach Mike Bellotti thusly:

It's a very obvious conclusion to reach. In intersectional competition, when you play against [the Big 12], I think you compare. You say, OK, the Pac-10 versus Big 12, if the Big 12 wins more of those games head-to-head, then they're the better league. If the Pac-10 wins, then we're a better league. . . . Certainly, the fans will look at it that way.

Miller notes that, in this weekend's college football action, four Pac-10 teams will be favored to beat Big 12 opponents in matchups between Arizona State and Colorado, Baylor and Washington State, Nebraska and Southern California, and Oklahoma and Oregon.

Much of the vitriol we see expended by those who are most vehement in decrying the so-called East Coast bias is directed at the Southeastern Conference. I have a simple question.

Why?

I understand the slights for which the Pac-10 seeks redress.

In 2001, Oregon was denied a berth in the national championship game, which went instead to . . . Nebraska, a team that did not win its division.

Some observers believe the Ducks were denied the Rose Bowl berth because test groups responded poorly to Mike Bellotti's hair, finding it "so '80s" when compared to Mack Brown's less dated mane.

In 2003, Southern California was denied a berth in the national championship game, which went instead to . . . Oklahoma, a team that did not win its conference.

In 2004, California was denied a berth in a B.C.S. bowl, which went instead to . . . Texas, a team whose head coach lobbied for the Rose Bowl bid.

Granted, the latter season also produced desperate attempts by Auburn to claim a piece of the national title, but the Tigers' case really boiled down to an argument that they deserved a chance to appear in the championship game opposite U.S.C. Instead, the role of preferred Orange Bowl loser went to . . . Oklahoma.

Am I the only one who sees a pattern here?

I'm not necessarily taking one league's side against the other's here, but it seems clear that the quarrel is between two particular conferences . . . and the S.E.C. ain't one of 'em.

Bias against the Pac-10? Not our fault. Rampant cheating? O.K., that we do.

The term "East Coast bias" often is taken to mean "pro-S.E.C. bias," but, whatever it may be, it assuredly is not that. If anything, E.S.P.N. displays an anti-S.E.C. bias and, while I agree with L.D. that the Worldwide Leader's decisions are strictly business, you can't argue that the boys from Bristol are prejudiced for the Southeastern Conference and against the Pacific-10 when "College GameDay" is shanghaied from Knoxville to Los Angeles.

Whenever the Pac-10 has had a gripe, though, it seems that the putative offending party hails from Big 12 country. Could it be that the S.E.C. is on the receiving end of misplaced anger that the league does not deserve?

If so, why is it that a conference that is merely an innocent bystander gets singled out for special criticism when the real culprits---if, indeed, culprits there be---are found to the right of the Pac-10 and to the left of the S.E.C.?

Perhaps it is wrong to portray this as a conflict between competing coasts, as though the Notorious S.E.C. were tangling with the Tupac-10. Maybe the real objects of West Coast fans' scorn are to be found not along the oceanfront, but in the continental middle.

Go 'Dawgs!

0 recs | Comment 3 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Great post as always Kyle
I am working on a piece of my own in regards to this subject, but with the breaking news about Reggie Bush I won't be able to finish it until the weekend.
Fight On!

by Paragon SC on Sep 15, 2006 8:08 AM EDT   0 recs

Gameday
I had started to think that after Gameday picked USC/Nebraska over LSU/Auburn for its host site. They're 3-0 for ABC/ESPN game as of now, right? I don't think we'll see them deviate from the site of the ABC Saturday Night Game unless it's a 7:45 p.m. ESPN game.

But those dots start to connect, don't they?

by Jmac on Sep 15, 2006 10:41 AM EDT   0 recs

Well, as long as Herbstreit is doing the games....
...I would think that's a no brainer. And as much as I think it sucks that they're going "family" of networks on us, if it keeps Herbstreit in that booth with Davie and !BRENT! and increases the chances of actually hearing a coherent thought, I'm all for it.

I think the Pac-10 has a persecution complex that's derived from their own insecurity, which is well placed insecurity. All of those "slights" to the Pac-10 have been covered Ad-nauseum, the media was the one that lept to Oregon & USC's defense in both of those cases. (Wrongly so, I might add.) While they immediately dismissed Auburn's grievence as trivial when USC blew out OU. (Wrongly so, again.) But yet the Pac-10 fans are so programmed to complain about everything.

There is an East Coast bias, but it has to do with 18 hours of consecutive coverage when the Red Sox and Yankees play a meaningless series and how Syracuse and Rutgers wind up somewhere on TV 7 times a year when no one, NO ONE, cares or how they have a college football pregame show from Times Square, you know where college football is king. And it has to do with the 300 articles a week on the "BCS Mess", while totally missing any coverage of any games and the relentless conversations which have turned the Heisman race into a podantic "What does MVP really mean to you" conversation. That is the east coast bias

by Jarvis12 on Sep 15, 2006 6:20 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Images_small
Behold Uga VII!
Avatar_small
Fantasy Football (Public and Private), Pickem Leagues, Confidence pools, etc... Good site
Will_queen_photo_small
On Fathers, Sons, and College Football
Small
What's the Deal?
Millers_crossing
Mayor, you may have lost your title
Millers_crossing
Which of these teams will reemerge as national contenders?
100_0141_small
Marcus Howard is loved in the pro's
Small
Georgia bar in LA???
36413436t_small
ASU Tix in Hand; You East Coasters Will Have them Today or Tomorrow
Uga_small
Sturdivant Injured?  NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

ad

Site Meter