Who Will Preview the Previewers?
One of the many things a man learns between the time he gets engaged and the time he gets married is that you can invite 40 people to your wedding, you can invite 125 people to your wedding, or you can invite 5,000 people to your wedding. No other numbers are possible. If you're going to invite one second cousin, one sorority sister, or one junior high classmate, you have to invite them all.

It's just going to be a small ceremony with a few family members and close friends. Right . . . and everybody who ever got stopped for a D.U.I. just had a couple of beers and everybody who comes in for an estate planning consultation just needs a simple will.
The same thing goes for preseason college football publications. You can pick one as your favorite (as, for instance, College Football Resource has done) and just buy that one. You can buy each of the four traditional preseason preview magazines (Athlon, Lindy's, Street & Smith's, and Sporting News) and stop there. However, if you buy any such magazines and you neither stop at one nor stop at four, you have to buy them all.
I fall in the "buy them all" category. Yes, it's obsessive. Yes, it's excessive. However, I just happen to be a 100 per cent sort of person.
So far, I have found three such publications on the magazine racks of local newsstands: Athlon, Lindy's, and Sporting News. I picked up the Southeastern Conference editions of each and I have summarized the salient details below for your ease of reference.

Image courtesy Athlon Sports.
Athlon Sports
Cover Photograph: Thomas Brown, Kregg Lumpkin, and Danny Ware.
Cover Blurb: "Dawgs Boast Nation's Best Backfield."
Overblown Cover Claim: "America's Premier Sports Annuals."
Edition: 40th
Pages and Paper Type: 256; slick.
National Champion Pick: Oklahoma.
Southeastern Conference Champion Pick: Florida.
S.E.C. East Champion Pick: Florida.
Georgia Ranking: No. 15; 2nd in S.E.C. East.
Interesting Factoid: "Georgia has been ranked in the Associated Press poll for 78 straight weeks. Only Miami and Texas have longer active streaks."
Annoying Tic: It's bad enough that my S.E.C. annual contains 25 pages devoted to Conference U.S.A., nine more devoted to the Sun Belt, and an additional 10 taken up by "regional teams" Louisiana Tech, Louisville, and South Florida. However, the four pages expended upon the Notre Dame Fighting Irish---also characterized as a "regional team" in S.E.C./Conference U.S.A./Sun Belt country, despite the fact that the school is located in Indiana---appear before the table of contents for the Southeastern Conference section . . . of the Southeastern Conference annual! If they want to include a few pages about the Golden Domers in the back of the magazine for the subway alumni, fine, but putting the Irish ahead of the S.E.C. in the S.E.C. preseason magazine is preposterous.

Image courtesy Lindy's Sports Annuals.
Lindy's
Cover Photograph: Mohamed Massaquoi (with Jenn Sterger inset).
Cover Blurb: "New Dawgs, Same Bite."
Overblown Cover Claim: "America's Leading Football Authority."
Edition: 25th
Pages and Paper Type: 224; slick.
National Champion Pick: Notre Dame.
Southeastern Conference Champion Pick: Florida.
S.E.C. East Champion Pick: Florida.
Georgia Ranking: No. 14; 2nd in S.E.C. East.
Interesting Factoid: "The Dawgs have four consecutive Top 10 AP finishes (only USC can also make that claim)."
Annoying Tic: On pages 92 and 93, the football annual provides its position-by-position rankings and lists the Red and Black as having the league's ninth-best Q.B. corps and eighth-best secondary. Clearly, the yutz who wrote that looked at the depth chart, didn't recognize the names, and didn't bother to do any digging. There may be fresh faces in the lineup in September, but, by November, no one will claim that there are eight better quarterbacks and seven better defensive backfields in the S.E.C. In fact, I'm pretty sure that, by the end of the season, no one will claim that there are eight better quarterbacks and seven better defensive backfields in the N.C.A.A. Also, could they have posted a dinkier picture of the magazine cover on their website?

Image courtesy The Sporting News.
The Sporting News
Cover Photograph: Auburn's Kenny Irons (with Alabama's Kenneth Darby inset).
Cover Blurb: "Ole Miss will go bowling."
Overblown Cover Claim: "Your Ultimate Guide to the nation's best league."
Edition: None noted.
Pages and Paper Type: 128; thick newspaper.
National Champion Pick: Notre Dame.
Southeastern Conference Champion Pick: Auburn.
S.E.C. East Champion Pick: Florida.
Georgia Ranking: No. 12; tied for 1st in S.E.C. East but losing the tiebreaker to the Gators.
Interesting Factoid: "The Dawgs have won 52 games in [Mark Richt's] five seasons, the most by a coach in his first five seasons in the school's storied history. More than Wally Butts or Harry Mehre or even---hushed tones, please---Vince Dooley. Fourteen more than Dooley."
Annoying Tic: Page 38 features three cheap shots at Ray Goff. On two occasions, he is referred to as "Goof" and, in another instance, the writer cracks, "Now, someone have Ray Goff go get Uga a bone." I was calling for Coach Goff to be fired five games into the 1993 season, so I have been as critical of Coach Dooley's successor as anyone, but Ray was a good guy, he's a Georgia man, and he's been gone for a decade. There's no excuse for making smart-aleck jokes at his expense at this stage of the game.

You can rag on Jim Donnan all you like, but leave poor Ray Goff alone.
I know Gator fans like the ones at Swamp Ball and Every Day Should Be Saturday are all over the preseason magazines, but surely I'm not the only loyal citizen of Bulldog Nation to have bought at least one of them.
Which ones have you purchased? What is your assessment of the best and worst of each? Let me know in the comments below.
Go 'Dawgs!
0 recs |
5
comments
Comments
got one
having written for these kinda things before (did an athalon basketball one once) the deadlines are too early for you to get too much accurate info in -- i was calling my editor once or twice a week with changes
by ctr on Jun 2, 2006 3:37 AM EDT 0 recs
Lindy's
I don't remember the rankings off the top of my head, but I think Arkansas was ahead of Georgia. That struck me as particularly odd, because JoeT3 beat Arkansas last year, and he might not even start the entire season due to Stafford's arrival on campus in Spring. Mustain will arrive in the Fall, but it makes no sense that the Hogs would be ranked above Georgia.
Aside from that, I realized that the writers for most of the previews had knowledge on par with my own...or maybe less. They all write in conjecture with little more than hearsay to back up their "projections." With the crap the MSM is putting out, is there any wonder why the blogosphere is becoming so popular?
by imarealist on Jun 2, 2006 8:29 AM EDT 0 recs
Ray Goff
Wasn't he an alum who took over after Dooley? I remember watching his Georgia teams on TBS ... and they always seemed to be underachieving.
Again what I am really interested in hearing (if he was an alum as I think he was) how difficult it was among Georgia fans to deal with the perceived underahcievement during his tenure.
by Nestor16 on Jun 2, 2006 9:35 AM EDT 0 recs
Thanks for the tip, Anonymous
However, following an exchange in a comment thread over at The M Zone, I promised Heismanpundit that, from that point forward, I would steer clear of him.
I have kept my word. Since that time, I have not visited his site and, aside from mentioning him in a single comment in connection with the aforementioned "Onepeat" dispute, my only reference to Heismanpundit, at Dawg Sports or in the comments left at any other weblog, came when I noted Heismanpundit's reasonable response to a posting of mine. As this arrangement has worked well while maintaining the peace in the blogosphere, I am disinclined to alter the balance that has been struck.
Even so, I certainly do not discourage my readers from reading Heismanpundit, as well, if they so choose. For those who may be interested, Sunday Morning Quarterback has continued the discussion. Be sure to read the comments, as well.
Thanks, and have a great weekend!
by T Kyle King on Jun 2, 2006 5:01 PM EDT 0 recs
You're a better man than I am
Good for you for having the patience to wait, though.
by T Kyle King on Jun 2, 2006 8:14 PM EDT 0 recs










