The Painfully Obvious
I posted this in the "You're on Notice!" thread, but figured I'd put this out as as a Fanpost to see if we are merely parroting each other, or if what I said is so painfully obvious to the DawgSports intelligentsia as myself and Inteljumper seem to think. If it is so obvious to us armchair quarterbacks, wouldn't it be painfully obvious to the much more experienced Coach Richt?
I held off on putting in my two cents directly after the game as I was still so frustrated. There are several things that stand out to me as painfully obvious:
1) Boise State was good and deserved their ranking. It’s obvious why most teams choose a cupcake to warm up with, we needed that. We have a lot of pieces on the field that might have won us the game later in the season, but we looked rusty. BSU looked experienced and ready to go. They are a very senior heavy team, and we are very young. That was very obvious Saturday.
2) Lack of adjustments to what was working or wasn’t working killed us. I have no idea why we continued to run it up the middle when it hadn't worked the whole game. I also have no idea why we didn’t run it to the outside when we got some of our biggest running gains out there, and where our "SEC speed"(!!) would have helped us.
3) Horrible, predictable playcalling. It’s so bad, and I know if it’s obvious to me what is coming next, then I’m sure the opposing D-Coordinator can figure out what we're going to do. "1st and bomb" is incomplete? No problem, run it up the middle for short or no gain. Then we're in 3rd and long, again. I would be interested to see how many 3rd and longs we were in Saturday compared with our 3rd and short situations. I'm pretty sure there were at least twice as many of the former. Talk about putting your inexperienced running backs (a true freshman and a reconverted linebacker to running back) in a bad spot. Murray is still only a sophomore, and he's getting trying to find his "go-to" receiver still.
4) First and bomb. Do I need to say any more? That gets us into point #3 again. Maybe it should also be added to the lexicon for Dawg Sports. It can be right next to FYG, which was probably said a lot on Saturday by Dawg fans.
5) Our offensive line looked woefully inadequate on Saturday. The combination of that and Murray stepping back too far in the pocket and hanging onto "the rock" too long is how we end up with 6 sacks. That and whiffed blocks by our tight end or running backs.
6) Crowell is definitely the future. For us to keep the ball out of his hands is hurting ourselves. That said, we need to play to his strengths. Runs to the outside, short dump passes to him, etc. Essentially, get him the ball and then see what he can do.
7) Same story with Malcolm Mitchell. That kid is a player. Get him the ball in high percentage routes and see what he can do after the catch. He should be starting always and be Murray’s #2 behind Orson Charles. Looks like Marlon Brown may have finally come into his own. Same story, get him the ball and see how many arm tackles he can break. Clearly King doesn’t have the speed or reach for the bombs that Green would have caught Saturday.
8) Let's see some short dumps like Moore and BSU did Saturday. As so many have said, that used to be our bread and butter with Greene. We have unproven receivers now and a weak to moderate line. That much is pretty obvious. High completion rates in the middle of the field and let the receivers and running backs make plays. When you've done some of those for first downs and aren't on your own 30 yard line, then throw a bomb occasionally.
That's about all I have to say, the season is by no means over, but South Carolina isn't going to be any easier. Maybe more familiar, but not easier. They always play us tough, and they have some guys named Garcia, Lattimore, and Clowney that will make it difficult for us. But if we execute and fix at least some of the above, I think we stand a good chance to win this and then move onto a somewhat easier part of our schedule.
Edit: Fixed some sppellung and grammar, mistakes.
39 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
But.....
You’ve probably never been in the arena…. (I have not)
Your real name is “Bulldog Joe”…… (Maybe mine is…)
You don’t know what the “hell you’re doing”…. (Not about coaching, but I’m not paid millions to do so)
One of the common feelings seems to be that the fanbase feels , well betrayed seems a bit strong, but that is what I will go with. The team, coaches and players, over-promised and under delivered.
The only change that was not made was the hiring of a new OC. Coach Richt may need to take more of a role in running the offense, if he wants to save his job.
Otherwise Kirby Smart will have a battle tested team to take over after leading Alabama’s defense to the MNC game
I don't disagree with any of this
However, we should have known that all the preseason hype was just that, hype. The other thing to say is that this is just one game, and that we lost to a higher ranked team that most expected us to lose to. We didn’t lose to an unranked D-2 school. We lost to a better team, that’s all there is to it.
We’ll see about Kirby. I’d love to have him, but you better believe Bama will match whatever we offer. If Richt is actually fired/resigns after this season, hopefully the pull of Kirby’s alma mater will be enough.
There's absolutely no doubt he'd take the job.
Kirby Smart almost took the defensive coordinator post at Georgia, making a lateral move by job description and a downward move in program strength. He’s biding his time until the right head coaching job comes along. Nick Saban consistently has urged his assistants not to make lateral moves, but he just as consistently has encouraged his assistants in pursuing jobs higher on the food chain.
If Mark Richt is fired and Kirby Smart gets the call, he’ll be Athens-bound. No question about that whatsoever.
Go 'Dawgs!
Good points
If it happens, so be it. If things stay the present course, we may be seeing him in Athens sooner than later. I’m not, and have never been, on the Fire Mark RichtRicht bandwagon, but it is hard to imagine that movement and group of boosters not picking up steam if we don’t show some improvement this year.
by andycapps on Sep 5, 2011 8:59 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
That's Coach Richt
Not RichtRicht. Dang you, autocorrect.
by andycapps on Sep 5, 2011 9:00 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
But should he get that call?
he hasn’t been a head coach at any level, and hasn’t even been in charge of scheming for his own unit with Saban as the defensive man in charge. Kirby might call the plays, but does anyone really believe Saban isn’t very hands on with that unit in practice, in the film room, and willing to veto any play he doesn’t want? Plus, would he keep his long time friend Bobo as OC, cause that’s a definite deal breaker.
A Smart/Leach combo would be intriguing though, with one as head man and the other in charge of the other side of the ball as coordinator. Don’t really care which would be which.
http://sportsandgrits.com/
I have it on record, I absolutely don't want KS to be at UGA. His ability to fire the old dawgs would be zero. His ability to stand up to the boosters would be zero.
This “come home” philosophy never works. KS would be pulled in 9 million directions, non of which would be being the best HC he could be.
The best hire in the last 11 years was CTG, because he can say “BS” and not have to worry about hurting some boosters or old friends. And he already did that. The only thing he said this last off season was “we held them to 10 points” (referring to the bowl). That statement was a statement..
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
I'm not advocating a course of action.
I’m saying what I think will happen.
I could be wrong, of course. I’ve been wrong before. If I had to put money on it, though, I’d bet on Mark Richt being fired at the end of the regular season and Kirby Smart being announced as the new head coach very shortly thereafter.
If the season continues the way it started, though, we’ll have ample time and incentive to discuss that subject in great depth.
Go 'Dawgs!
Kirby Smart does bring some advantages though
For one, I would guess that most of Richt’s coaching staff, at least including Bobo, would be shown the door. Grantham is probably new enough and has been there a short enough time that he may be okay, providing that Grantham doesn’t give him too much overlap. Still, I’m not saying I advocate firing Grantham at all, but there would at least be some good transition as we have recruited and know a 3-4 fairly well now, which would make Smart more at home.
I have to think that Smart would be a workhorse like Saban and would bring in new blood that would think the way he does. I don’t see him keeping a ton of old timers around.
Honestly all of this just feels so premature to discuss after one game being played, but if you’re betting that Richt will be fired and Smart hired at the end of this season, then I should start preparing myself for that inevitability. As much as I like Richt as a person, some drastic staff changes would be needed during midseason to save himself, or things will have to magically gel immediately.
by andycapps on Sep 5, 2011 11:08 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
There will be more on this later:
but firing a HC usually results in everyone else going out the the door as well, minus some “old dawg” that is a recruiter or line coach or some such.
Do you really think Kirby Smart will tell Joe T to get lost? I don’t, And it takes that kind of strength to be an “elite” HC. ala, Nick Saban.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
Joe T
Would probably be relegated to an administrative job, it’s not right to fire someone after that many years at the university. I would think KS would bring in new blood for pretty much everything. As the head recruiter, Garner may be safe.
by andycapps on Sep 6, 2011 8:53 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
No one has been strong enough to tell JT to get lost. You think a new, young HC will?
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
What we need is a new, young guy who's not afraid to step on toes and shake things up.
He could get things done, sweep out the old guard, and re-establish the name “Georgia” in the minds of all the college football world.
You know, just like Lane Kiffin did for Tennessee.
I am just afraid of the "UGA Lettermen" old boy network. If KS tells everyone to go to hell, then he's my hero.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
What was he really doing before this promotion?
He was an assistant strength and conditioning coach, correct? He could get demoted to that again, or get pushed to an administratitve job like I mentioned (ala Van Hallanger).
You bring this up about Kirby Smart, but if he can’t bring in new blood, who could? If you want to go completely new blood, then we’re talking Chris Petersen, etc. That carries a new level of risk as we’re all familiar with what happens when you take a guy from a winning program (on a lesser stage) and bring them to the SEC. Donnan. That’s what happens. Or he could be like Urban Meyer and succeed, but he’s the exception to the rule.
As far as candidates for the job go, I don’t think we can do much better for Kirby Smart. He’s a UGA grad, he’s been away long enough to bring in new and “Sabanized” ideas, etc. There would be a focus on defense that we probably haven’t seen since the early Richt years.
I believe we need a modern, young, new age S&C guy -
what worked in 1976 is not what is happening today. I dont hate Joe T. I would be proud to shake his hand. However, he is not where modern bodybuilding and conditioning is.
Also, i am not on the “Fire CMR” bus. I am on the “Fire CMB as OC and get a newly educated workout coach” bus.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
by chuckdawg on Sep 6, 2011 6:22 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
I agree with every word of that, tankertoad.
With regard to Kirby Smart, who works with Scott Cochran and knows what a cutting-edge strength coach looks like, I believe he would move Joe Tereshinski back into an administrative role (where he’s been for lo these many years) and bring in a Scott Cochran disciple.
Go 'Dawgs!
I agree with this
However, I don’t think Richt will fire CMB, so that may in itself seal CMR’s fate.
by andycapps on Sep 6, 2011 9:53 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
this is word for word what I told the mayor on the phone
But it brings me no pride, joy, happiness, goodness, It makes me sad.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
by chuckdawg on Sep 7, 2011 2:05 AM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
Lost to a better team...
We lost to a better team, that’s all there is to it.
Isn’t that a red flag to begin with when Boise State is clearly a better team than Georgia?
by FisheriesDawg on Sep 5, 2011 11:17 PM EDT up reply actions
Not after the past several years
While Boise State has been improving, we’ve been getting worse. Yes, I suppose it’s a red flag as in we should not be okay with that, but to be in denial of the above taking place seems silly. So I reiterate that we lost to a better team.
by andycapps on Sep 5, 2011 11:22 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I don't care about the past several years.
We complain about falling behind programs like Florida and Alabama, and we’re on relatively equal footing with them. Boise would kill to have the inherent advantages that come with our program.
by FisheriesDawg on Sep 6, 2011 9:12 AM EDT up reply actions
I'm not sure I understand your point
And I’m not trying to be rude.. Boise State is a better program than us in one game. Do I think they could win the SEC West this year? No way, they don’t have the depth for that. But their first team can definitely match up against our first team and most others for one game.
Through coaching, scheming, and development, they’ve maximized what they can get out of their athletes, while some here would contend that we haven’t done that for the great athletes that we have.
You understand exactly the point...
though it isn’t just one game. We would have lost nine out of ten times on Saturday night.
They’ve maximized what they can get out of their athletes. We haven’t. They don’t even have the caliber of athletes that we do (or at least shouldn’t given our inherent advantages) yet we’re still to the point that they’re humiliating us on national TV just six years after we completely put them in their place.
by FisheriesDawg on Sep 6, 2011 10:30 AM EDT up reply actions
We're saying pretty much the same thing
However, I’m saying that they played well against us and beat us because they were the better team. Would they be the better team after playing a 12 game regular season including their (theoretical) SEC conference slate? That’s doubtful.
But we both agree that there’s a lot of talent being wasted on this team. They have less talent than they do and made more of it, and yes, they’d win 9 out of 10 times if we replayed the game.
We should have known that the hype was hype...................
Maybe for some but I expect more than hype. It is just one game (I’m tired of that phrase) – it is the third year of the same game which in my mind is a bit more than one.
by JRL on Sep 7, 2011 4:13 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
This is nonsense
Coach Richt is a fine and honest man, and will lead us all into a new day! You must be a fairweather fan, Andycapps. Be gone!
woof woof
I see what you did here
It’s okay guys, nothing to see here. Just a little heckling from a member of another board that I linked this on. :) Thanks for the comment anyway!
:P
Honestly, feel bad for ya’lls situation. To get rid of a stagnent coach, even if he’s UGAs #2 coach of all time, its soul destroying.
Just dont take Kirby ;)
I think the problem is that
He may be our #2 coach of all time, but is he going to come back and return to his winning ways like your own Bear Bryant did? Or how our own Vince Dooley did? Does our fanbase have the patience for that in the era of blogs like this, or ESPN 1, 2, ESPNU, etc?
Getting rid of our offensive coordinator would be a step towards appeasing fans and maybe getting rid of some of the nonsensical playcalling, but I don’t think Richt will do it. He’s too loyal and that may end up being his own downfall by the end of the season if he can’t at least pull out an 8-4.
I hope we don't
I don’t see how hiring an unproven who’s never schemed his own unit and would probably continue some of the good friends club we’ve got going makes us any different.
http://sportsandgrits.com/
Allow me to apologize for the earlier barking and snipping
And extend a hand of friendship, seeing how you are a known outsider.
Welcome.
Success is never final. --Winston Churchill
True...
But there’s a difference between rivalry and hatred. I try to limit the latter.
Success is never final. --Winston Churchill
I know - I know................
Recruiting rankings are hit and miss but………… Over the last ten years we have averaged being # 3 in the SEC and # 7 nationally – WTF happened? Everybody has casualties and I doubt we have had that many more than the rest. From this seat I think we have failed to develop and or utilize the talent and that points towards a lack of coaching.

by 
































