Assume The Position: Previewing The Georgia Quarterbacks.
The Georgia Bulldog football team will hit the practice field beginnning this Thursday in preparation for the 2011 football season. As practice picks up steam, we here at Dawg Sports will be taking a position-by-position look at the players who Mark Richt will be counting on to deliver this fall. We begin with the quarterbacks.
It seems like forever since the Georgia Bulldogs began the season with a returning starter at the quarterback position. In reality, that last occurred heading into the 2008 campaign, when Matthew Stafford returned for his second year as the fulltime QB1 after wrangling the job from a gang of challengers during 2006. Stafford led the 'Dawgs to a 10-3 slate, which at the time seemed disappointing for a squad ranked as a consensus preseason #1. In the harsh light of subsequent events, our collective disappointment seems quaint. If Aaron Murray leads the Georgia Bulldogs to a 10-3 season in 2011 I think the reaction of Bulldog fans would be decidedly different. That's because the upcoming season is one of questions. Including . . .
If Aaron Murray's numbers fall and A.J. Green's not around to stop it, is it really a sophomore slump?
There's been some discussion in the blogosphere about the potential for Aaron Murray to endure a sophomore slump. To be fair, he wouldn't be the first signalcaller to endure such an outcome. And with A.J. Green set to be snagging passes for the Cincinnati Bengals come September, one would hardly be surprised if Murray found himself desperately seeking targets.
And when you get right down to it, Aaron Murray doesn't lack targets. He lacks proven targets. Once or twice last year I mentioned my belief that concerns over Georgia's receiving corps outside of Green and Kris Durham were misplaced. To recap, it's like this. There are really only so many times you can throw the ball. And when Mike Bobo had A.J. Green and Kris Durham, soon to be first day NFL draft picks, to throw to he would be nuts to throw elsewhere. That's probably why those two receivers accounted for 42.5% of Aaron Murray's 209 completions.
And while A.J. Green is truly a singular talent, he's not irreplaceable. Green's talent can't be duplicated in one guy, but his production can be split among a variety of receivers. Tavarres King reminds me a little of Sean Bailey in terms of his speed/skill combination. Marlon Brown has earned consistent praise from coaches. Rantavious Wooten has been incredibly effective when he's been healthy. And that's before we consider the logjam of tight end targets. In other words, Aaron Murray is going to have plenty of people to throw the ball to. That's not the thing to worry about.
Rather, the greatest danger to Aaron Murray's health and sanity this fall will not be the absence of A.J. Green. It will be the danger that Mike Bobo, Will Friend and a thin offensive line can't engineer a rushing attack. It's this simple: The Bulldogs were 6-2 during 2010 in games in which they rushed for 130+ yards. The two losses were to Arkansas and Colorado in losses directly attributable to untimely sprained cerebrums in the running back corps*. They were 0-5 when rushing for fewer than 130. Obviously correlation does not equal causation. Except when the correlation holds true over and over and over again, week in and week out.
One would hope that the relationship works in reverse and that a renewed, consistent Bulldog running game would equate to wins. One thing we know for certain is that in Georgia's pro-style, play action based passing game. the lack of a credible running threat makes throwing the ball tougher. The lack of a consistent running game in 2010 was also likely responsible for Aaron Murray's 342 passing attempts in 2010, more than senior Joe Cox had in 2009 and certainly more than coaches would have preferred to ask from a freshman signalcaller. Aaron Murray also spent more time in the shotgun in 2009 than any Georgia QB of recent vintage, probably to give hima better view of the field, and some cover against an offensive line that rarely looked the same from week to week. All of which is to say that if the running game comes along as I hope, Aaron Murray may have fewer pass attempts, fewer yards passing and more wins.
Walking The Mason-Fixin' Line
I anticipate that Hutson Mason will remain the #2 quarterback on the depth chart and that Christian LeMay will redshirt to create some class separation. I am a little concerned about Mason's remarks during the offseason that he will have to figure out what to do if he's not redshirted to gain some class separation from Murray. I would truly hate to see us lose a guy who I think has a lot of potential to be a solid #2 for the next 3 seasons.
However, I also know that Hutson Mason is unlikely to have the opportunity that Joe Cox did to start as a senior when his classmate leaves early to accept a sackful of money from an NFL owner. Aaron Murray may ultimately be even more effective as a collegiate quarterback than Matt Stafford was (and the early numbers are clearly promising). However unless he hits an unusual growth spurt he'll never be the 6'3-6'4, rocket-armed prototype quarterback that pro football personnel-types covet. That's good for you and I because it means that Aaron Murray's not likely to enter the NFL Draft until he runs out of college eligibility. It's bad news for Hutson Mason because as things stand now, he'll run out of collegiate eligibility on the same day as Murray, and without having his day in the sun.
Ideally, Christian LeMay will use his early enrollment to gain a handle on the playbook and be ready to play this season, allowing the coaches the option of letting Mason redshirt if he wants to. Of course if that occurs the coaches will merely shift the dilemma from a Murray/Mason problem to a LeMay/Mason problem (as playing LeMay would make he and Mason each redshirt sophomores in 2012). LeMay came to Athens as highly touted a high school quarterback as Aaron Murray. It will be interesting to see exactly how patient he is to play. However after skipping his last season of high school football, LeMay might be well-served with a redshirt season. As long as Aaron Murray stays healthy most of this drama is irrelevant for the present. Interesting, but not relevant. However, if (perish the thought) something happens to Murray, the Mason/LeMay battle will become high stakes drama in a hurry.
The bottom line is that when you recruit a talented high school quarterback every year some of them are just going to have to wait their turns to play, and if they're the kind of competitors you hope they are, none of them will really like it. Some will never get their chance, and them's the breaks. Trying to figure out which of our talented quarterbacks to play is a good problem to have, and this is one of the few personnel grouping where this sort of problem exists. Let's enjoy it.
And Then There Was One (More Quarterback On The Roster)
Remember that redshirt freshman and Wayne County product Parker Welch is waiting in the wings as the 4th string quarterback. I point him out principally because as a fan I appreciate his hard work and sacrifice for the good of the team every day in practice, and because I hope to later see him on the field a couple of times this season and be able to link back to this post when that time comes. A blogger can dream, after all. Unti next time . . .
Go 'Dawgs!!!
*Spoiler: When we preview the running backs I'll be asking why Bryan McClendon isn't buying Mike Bobo lunch every day for creating a distraction on his behalf Stay tuned.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Obvious solution to QB redshirt problems
Red-shirt Mason this season (LeMay’s readiness obviously plays an important part in this). Next year, red-shirt LeMay. That way, each is one year off the other, we retain a viable backup in the case of injury, and each is guaranteed at least a year of starting opportunity (although, if LeMay passes Mason, we may still lose Mason to another school after his Junior year).
I'd be just fine
With no one having the opportunity Joe Cox did to start their senior year…. even though that worked out so swimmingly.
In all seriousness, I think Mason is a talented QB but I’d rather not throw the depth chart, recruiting, and ultimately the offense into a tizzy to satisfy seniority or loyalty again. If Mason thinks he has more of an opportunity to play elsewhere, more power to him (though I would miss the depth he might provide).
"If there's one thing worse than chlamydia, it's Florida." ~ Emma Stone
by RedCrake on Aug 1, 2011 10:55 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
Exactly.
Mason is a solid player but will have to really come alive to be an SEC starter. LeMay has a good chance to be a top-flight QB no matter the league. LeMay could challenge Murray for a starting job. Don’t lose LeMay for Mason. Mason knew or should have known all of this when he signed up to play in Athens: he might not have known LeMay’s name, but he knew that somebody like him would be coming. He was counting on starting, he picked the wrong school or looked into one of those magic mirrors that only shows you what you want to see.
Let him compete for the job. If he doesn’t like the outcome, that’s why they call it competing.
by first and thom on Aug 2, 2011 7:00 AM EDT up reply actions
Are we sleeping on Mason?
He’s the only guy we have that has even close to prototypical size. Every time I see the guy, he seems to have good presence and better than average arm.
I mean either way, I have no loyalties to any of the backups yet. I just want what’s best for the Dawgs.
Touchdown Georgia!!!!!
I think we are.
It may come to pass that Mason does not have what it takes to be a great (or even good enough) UGA QB. However, regardless of how highly touted LeMay was and is, he ain’t done for me yet what Mason’s already done — play ball for Georgia.
by NCT on Aug 2, 2011 5:48 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
I don't.
I think that Mason can be as good as Joe Cox. I watched him play in HS (go trojans!) and, while he had an incredible numerical performance, I didn’t see from him the kind of dominating QB presence you get from UGA QBs. He was a winner in a system, but I don’t think he’s the kind of guy who can take the game on his shoulders and carry it. I think he’s more of a Malzahn QB – quick reads, lots of options, not afraid to run, but not possessed of an arm cannon.
Don’t get me wrong, I am glad he’s with us and want him to stay. Tall, smart, accurate passers who can run don’t just grow on trees. But unless something has fundamentally changed in the past two years, I don’t see any reason to put a finger on the scales in favor of Mason against LeMay. Whichever of them wins the competition should stay, even if it means losing the other.
by first and thom on Aug 3, 2011 3:04 PM EDT up reply actions
I have no knack for evaluating prospects.
I’m doing pretty well just to evaluate performance on the field to any degree of subtlety beyond the final score.
I’m not arguing that Mason should be favored over LeMay, except Mason has playing experience as a member of the UGA football team and LeMay does not. If and when we get to the point where we need to put one of them on the field, and if the coaches tell me that their practice evaluations show them that LeMay will contribute better, experience level notwithstanding, then I’m fine with that. But it seemed to me that folks have been dismissing Mason out of hand in favor of a very highly touted prospect who has never played a down of football for UGA and, for that matter, hasn’t played a down of football for team at any level in nearly two years.
by NCT on Aug 3, 2011 4:36 PM EDT up reply actions
That's fair.
I think I sound argumentative, and I don’t want to. I think you’re being reasonable, but I still disagree,
There’s a ditch on both sides of the road. It’s possible that we could be favoring the touted recruit over the proven commodity. It’s also possible that we’re valuing a proven commodity over a player whose upside is higher. As I look at the last few years, we have been much closer to the “too much loyalty” ditch than the “cutthroat reliance on the newest hotshot recruit” ditch. A year in the system is valuable (as is throwing a TD pass on your first attempt in Sanford Stadium), but it’s not a huge deal – especially when both guys will be part of the team this year. It’s too late for either to transfer now.
by first and thom on Aug 3, 2011 6:36 PM EDT up reply actions
Except he's not playing QB...
as he didn’t think the demands of that position could work with his desire to also play basketball. So he’s a DB.
http://sportsandgrits.blogspot.com/

by 































