Why Did the Atlanta Journal-Constitution Drop the Ball on the Demaryius Thomas Story?
As I noted following the announcement that the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets had been placed on probation following a 20-month investigation that managed to occur without even a whisper of media attention, it has not been a proud week for old media. I was not alone in making this observation.
Paul Westerdawg did not exaggerate when he wrote that the Engineers benefited from having "a hometown newspaper completely and totally asleep at the wheel," and, while Senator Blutarsky concurred that it was "an embarrassment to the sports section of a major newspaper that’s clearly seen better days before," he offered an alternative explanation:
No doubt some of what Paul is critical of is related to public interest. There are many more fans of Georgia’s program than there are of Tech’s and what resources the AJ-C has to direct in its sports coverage are going to go more in the direction of Athens than the Flats because that’s where the eyeballs are. If the readership isn’t particularly interested, it’s harder to convince the paper’s editors to be concerned.
The Senator’s take echoed that of SB Nation Atlanta’s Jason Kirk, who wrote:
For one thing, the priority of the Atlanta media will always be on SEC schools over ACC schools, even when we're talking about in-state institutions. That's just the way it is, based on audience interest.
While Jason’s and the Senator’s points are true as far as they go, I don’t think those arguments go as far as they suppose. Yes, there are a lot more fans of the Georgia Bulldogs in the Peach State than there are fans of the Ramblin’ Wreck; that is a function of many factors, including the facts that (i) the Red and Black have been the more successful football program overall for most of the last two decades and have had the upper hand in the rivalry for nearly half a century, (ii) the University of Georgia’s enrollment is roughly triple that of the Georgia Institute of Technology, and (iii) a bigger chunk of Georgia Tech’s student body comes from outside the borders of the Empire State of the South, and is more likely to leave the state after graduation.
However, it isn’t as simple as suggesting that, because there are more Georgia fans than there are Georgia Tech fans, the readership of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution doesn’t care at all about the Golden Tornado. Oh, sure, a lot fewer people want to be kept abreast of positive developments at the Flats, but let’s be frank: this was bad news for Georgia Tech. Georgia Tech fans are interested in bad news about Georgia Tech because it’s about Georgia Tech. Georgia fans are interested in bad news about Georgia Tech because it’s bad news and we enjoy the Jacketfreude. Fans of every stripe enjoy watching their rivals squirm; it is an attribute inherent in sports fandom, for some more than others, but for all to some extent.
Would 20 months of local media coverage of an ongoing NCAA investigation into Georgia Tech’s football and men’s basketball programs have generated interest in the Atlanta market? Sure it would have, and the fact that boosters of the Bulldogs make up a larger share of that market doesn’t change that fact. It simply does not follow that the Journal-Constitution knew of the investigation and made a business decision to sit on the story in absolute silence for over a year and a half because the powers that be in the local press believed no one in the Atlanta area would care.
The simple truth is that the Journal-Constitution dropped the ball. Look at all the media attention that has been drawn by recent inquiries and investigations concerning the USC Trojans, Alabama Crimson Tide, North Carolina Tar Heels, South Carolina Gamecocks, Ohio St. Buckeyes, Oregon Ducks, LSU Tigers, Auburn Tigers, and, yes, Georgia Bulldogs. Granted, this weblog scooped the mainstream media by being the first to break the news of A.J. Green’s four-game suspension, but at least professional journalists were on the story.
After the NCAA dropped the hammer on the Yellow Jackets, Mark Bradley wondered why Dan Radakovich still had his job, given the substandard manner in which this matter was managed. Radakovich fairly might ask the same question about Bradley, and his colleagues. Lewis Grizzard is dead, and the Journal-Constitution shouldn’t feel too good itself.
Go ‘Dawgs!
25 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Do we really need an explanation why the AJC dropped the ball?
This is the AJC we’re talking about. It ain’t exactly the New York Times, y’know.
by SWRT on Jul 16, 2011 12:42 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
I asumed they dropped the ball . . .
because in that critical moment when it mattered most Bebe Thomas was actually the guy in charge of catching it.
/You throw on 4th down.
//It’s not successful.
///You call another pass play on 5th down.
////You’re Patrick Nix.
I'm glad you saw . . .
. . . what I did there.
Go 'Dawgs!
by T Kyle King on Jul 16, 2011 11:40 AM EDT up reply actions
Why did the AjC drop the ball?
Because like most of the modern media, it’s populated by opinion columnists masquerading as journalists.
The mainstream media can mock the blogosphere all they want but at the end of the day many sports blogs (including this one) have writers that care more about research and accuracy than those who are paid to do so.
"If there's one thing worse than chlamydia, it's Florida." ~ Emma Stone
by RedCrake on Jul 16, 2011 1:13 AM EDT via mobile reply actions 2 recs
Can I get an amen?
Cry 'Havoc,' and let slip the Dawgs of war; - Julius Caesar, Act III, Scene 1
/tankertoad says, “And let the choir say…”
//vineyarddawg says, “… I hate Florida.”
by vineyarddawg on Jul 16, 2011 11:00 AM EDT up reply actions
which is why I wanted to vote for both option 2 and 3
incompetence and a lack of resources in a dying paper.
http://sportsandgrits.blogspot.com/
by Mr. Sanchez on Jul 16, 2011 10:01 AM EDT up reply actions
I don't know, but
I do know that Gannett is sucking wind… HARD! I think there were some layoffs in DC at US Today. I actually had a nightmare last night that WXIA was shutting down their news operations and my best friend was going to lost his job.
It’s dark days for TV news, but even worse for newspapers. I think investing in print media is one of Warren Buffet’s biggest regrets.
to be fair
It seems like most papers are getting beat by web outlets like yahoo and blogs (at least in the cfb news dept.). Other than the Columbus dispatch’s last round of tressel revelations (and our own Columbus ledger’s minor scoop of the dumb rec dept. variety), I can’t remember the last story hat was broken by a paper. We joke locally about no one caring about tech, but its definitely true nationally. And I think the ajc is a great paper, its the columnists that piss me off. I just ignore them. As for former columnists, Furman Bisher can shampoo my crotch.
by Mark Mandingo on Jul 16, 2011 9:08 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
Great question
not just UGA fans are interested. The AJC has no qualms about reporting negatively on SEC schools … yet Tech is the midst of a major two-year, two-sport investigation and not a peep from the hometown paper?
If there was a young man who was choosing between the Jackets and Dawgs over the last 20 months .. .or even the Jackets and Clemson, or Wake, or wherever … can’t we agree he had a right to know if the team was being investigated? Isn’t that the job of the ethical sports media? Did Paul Johnson tell recruits there was an investigation? Was he asked about it by concerned parents? Are there players who matriculated at Tech who would have looked to another school had they known the whole truth? Did the AJC and Tech collude to supress news in order to protect Tech or Paul Johnson?
Atlanta is the biggest city in the South and a recruiting hotbed for more than just the local universities. The AJC is one of the biggest sport departments in the region covering the two biggest conferences in the Southland. The AJC’s editorial positons impact programs and sports reporting far beyond the Georgia state lines. With this prominence, however, comes concomitant responsibility. We all have a right to know if the AJC set on a big story to protect hometown favorites. If it did, it’s an even bigger fishwrapper than I had previously thought.
If the AJC can truthfully and credibly state it had no knowledge of the investigation either, then it raises an even more important question … are some NCAA investigations more secret than others? South Carolina is being investigated for the Whitney hotel mess. UNC is being investigated for serious allegations of academic fraud and coaches fronting for agents. Auburn, Ohio State and Oregon look to be in even deeper kimchee.
At least we all know about these investigations – they are all matters of public record.
Does that mean other schools have secret investigations? What if Florida was being secretly investigated now? What about Bama? Or FSU? Wouldn’t you want to know? Shouldnt we have a right to know? The system needs major reform.
But first the AJC needs to answer – what did they know about Tech and when did they know it?
Here's a health, Carolina, forever to thee! UNIVERSITAS CAROLIN MERID. 1801 Emollit mores nec sinit esse feros (Ovid)
by tryptic67 on Jul 16, 2011 10:48 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
I voted for
lack of resources. I mulled over the “incompetence” option, but I couldn’t really do this. And here is why. I truly believe that Bradley and Schultz exist to sling hash on UGA. Since this is their primary task, they are completely competent because they do it so well. No one has accused these guys actually being journalists, have they? I honestly can’t tell you who is the Tech beat writer because I don’t read Tech news. In fact, I rarely read the AJC. I’m occasionally guided there by the links provided by TheDawgbone.com and other Georgia-centric blogs.
However, this whole incident really speaks to the bigger tragedy of the dying news dailies. I’m not even going to talk about television because, even when local TV was thriving, they derived much of their “scoops” from raiding the types of stories that once-great newspapers already broke. Local television is parasitic that way. Trust me. That’s not to say that some local TV stations don’t employ some solid, dedicated investigative journalists…but they, too, are becoming increasingly rare.
Back on point: It is sad to see the types of service to the greater good which the newspaper journalists once regularly provided by doing the kind of investigative journalism that broke stories such as the Watergate scandal, or other all-too-familiar tales of local corruption that would have gone unabated if not for local print media as watchdogs.

Irwin R. Fletcher is dead. Long Live Fletch!
"If we score, we may win. If they never score, we'll never lose."
-Erk Russell
by DavetheDawg on Jul 16, 2011 11:07 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
furman bisher is an asshat.
that is all.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
by kleph on Jul 16, 2011 11:52 AM EDT reply actions 3 recs
Because they suck. (concision)
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
FWIW
Bubba Watson made the cut at the Open, however he is currently tied for 33 and likely won’t be in the money.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
After a furious Friday blog, it's damn quiet today.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
My "WTF?" piece on the Jim Donnan story . . .
. . . is scheduled to be posted at 12:15 tonight.
Go 'Dawgs!
I havent written it, but I got a rough idea on "top ten reasons to hate BSU"
that should cause a skyrocket of hits from BSU and make me very loved.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
I fully expect
the NCAA to slap us with 4 years of retroactive probation.
"If we score, we may win. If they never score, we'll never lose."
-Erk Russell
by DavetheDawg on Jul 16, 2011 10:05 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Unless we are talking pacific time - fail.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
by tankertoad on Jul 17, 2011 1:39 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions

by 





























