Mark Richt States His Position On Oversigning As Succinctly As Possible: "The Question Is Everybody's Integrity."
I had a chance to catch up with Coach Mark Richt at today's Peach State Pigskin Preview here in Macon. A lot of the expected subjects came up, and I'll certainly discuss those in the coming days. But a topic that everyone expected to come up, oversigning, actually drew a response that I thought was pretty darned telling.
First, a little background. As you'll recall, at the recent SEC Meetings in Destin SEC coaches unanimously voted against a "roster management proposal" crafted by the league's university presidents and put forth by Commissioner Mike Slive. The presidents passed the proposal over the coaches' objections, and one consequence of that is a new cap of 25 players per signing class in football, down from the prior limit of 28. The skepticism about the proposal became evident from the get-go, and it appears that Mark Richt shares that sentiment, as he led a group of assembled media members through a little math lesson:
"I'll just say this, you guys can figure it out. 85 on scholarship. If 15 guys leave, how many do you have room for? It's not a trick question. How many do you have room for? . . . [A media member responds "15"]. . . Is 25 more than 15? So I don't know if you're catching my drift of what I'm trying to say, but . . . all I'm saying is you could still oversign with 25. If you only have room for 15 and you sign 25 you're still signing more than you've got. The question is everybody's integrity. That's the question. Are we all going to do things in the right way? And I think everybody's trying to do that.
But it's not an easy thing, it really is not. Because on Signing Day if you sign right to the 85 number by the time August rolls around you might have only 79 because of the attrition that happens from Signing Day to August, and that's what everybody's trying to figure out. How can we start the season at 85 and not oversign, you know what I mean? And it's not as simple as everybody makes it out to be."
Mark Richt's not the kind of guy to call anyone out publicly. But that's about as close as he's going to get. Reading between the lines I think he's acknowledging that by agreeing to a hard scholarship limit some of his fellow coaches are definitely hampering their ability to compete. There's a natural tension there. Everyone wants to win, and everyone wants to do everything within the rules to win. But at the same time, giving out 25 scholarships when you have 70 eligible scholarship athletes who want to return to your school and compete the following season requires either hoping for divine intervention or creatively pushing some guys aside whose parents were recently promised that their son would be taken care of. The numbers simply don't lie. Mark Richt is right. 25 is more than 15.
Over the next couple of days it will be interesting to see how this very public proclamation of basic arithmetic resonates across SEC country. I'll be waiting here with my popcorn. Until later . . .
Go 'Dawgs!!!
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This is the dilemma, and nice to see that he recognizes the first (I bolded it) part...
in addition to the well documented morality of the second part.
Because on Signing Day if you sign right to the 85 number by the time August rolls around you might have only 79 because of the attrition that happens from Signing Day to August, and that’s what everybody’s trying to figure out. How can we start the season at 85 and not oversign, you know what I mean? And it’s not as simple as everybody makes it out to be.
It’s not simple, how do you give your team the best chance to win (being as close to 85 scholarshipped athletes as possible) and not oversign even a little, which creates the risk of someone getting squeezed if natural attrition isn’t as much as you expect come that first Wed in February?
http://sportsandgrits.blogspot.com/
It's also a question of who ought to absorb the risk
If you have 15 spots, and you sign 20 betting that five of those will be lost to grades, pro contracts, sprained cerebrums, etc., but then your attrition turns out to be more like three, then either somebody’s getting the Spurrier/Miles treatment or a grayshirt. Either way, whatever risk there is is being absorbed by the players.
At some point, what are the odds you see a players and parents association form, similar to the NFL Players Association, to hold the NCAA’s feet to the fire on this?
SEC Pigskin Podcast with Barney Able and Dorsey Hill
http://www.secpigskinpodcast.com/
it's been attempted if I'm not mistaken...
but the logistics of getting a group that large, with such constant turnover and uncertainty, together is near impossible. And Richt has talked about it being OK if you’re up front about it. Say we’re sitting with 3-5 extra after signing day, provided he’s got 2-4 of those guys willing to grey shirt if necessary, that’d be an easy answer to the possible problem of what if attrition is less than expected.
http://sportsandgrits.blogspot.com/
No, I get the grayshirting logic.
But right now, that’s merely an option for coaches, not a requirement. To my knowledge, coaches are under no obligation to provide grayshirts or, really, do anything to honor the scholarship offers they make. The commitment is purely one-sided, player to school. That’s how a player at LSU can have a dorm room at LSU and then suddenly not even have a scholarship.
SEC Pigskin Podcast with Barney Able and Dorsey Hill
http://www.secpigskinpodcast.com/
by aproposdenada on Jun 14, 2011 4:21 PM EDT up reply actions
By the way . . .
I don’t think I’ve ever properly congratulated you on your profile picture. There are hardly words.
Thank you sir.
I’ll admit, I’m a little surprised it’s taken this long for anyone to notice. I put it up shortly before the Georgia-Auburn game, when L’Affaire Newton was hitting full stride. ’Bout time the world caught up to me.
SEC Pigskin Podcast with Barney Able and Dorsey Hill
http://www.secpigskinpodcast.com/
by aproposdenada on Jun 14, 2011 3:59 PM EDT up reply actions
It's a really small picture...
… but once I clicked through to your profile page, I was duly impressed.
Bravo, sir. Bravissimo.
by vineyarddawg on Jun 14, 2011 4:45 PM EDT up reply actions
brilliance in little things
It’s all about the fundamentals!
by first and thom on Jun 14, 2011 4:54 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs

by 





























