If You Wonder Why Georgia Fans Are So Mad About Last Saturday . . .
. . . just read the article linked to above.
Dr. Saturday is one of the best college football weblogs out there (and it should be noted that Matt Hinton didn't write this), but the popular media meme has taken hold even in that most respected corner of the blogosphere.
The video of James Franklin's tirade during the postgame handshake, which shows Mark Richt conducting himself with class and underscores the extent to which Coach Franklin was the instigator of the whole thing, is distorted to suggest that Coach Richt expected his defensive coordinator to tee off on an opposing coach.
A comparison is then drawn to last year's incident in Jacksonville. Last year, you will recall, Todd Grantham directed an inappropriate gesture and an inappropriate remark toward an opposing player. He was wrong to do so, and I said so at the time.
Last Saturday, James Franklin directed an inappropriate gesture and an inappropriate remark toward an opposing player. He was wrong to do so, and Todd Grantham said so at the time. The proper comparison to what Coach Grantham did last year is to what Coach Franklin did last Saturday, not to what Coach Grantham did in response.
If such basic facts are being missed even by weblogs typically as keenly perceptive as Dr. Saturday, well, the rest of the world shouldn't wonder why Bulldog Nation is as incensed as Coach Grantham.
Coach Franklin is the bad guy here. Fight the real enemy!
Go 'Dawgs!
7 months ago
T Kyle King
5 comments
0 recs |
Comments
Honestly...
At this point, who cares? As long as the people who matter understand what happened (SEC, UGA, our fans), I don’t really care anymore.
UGA cannot win in this situation for a couple of reasons:
First, it’s Vandy, so the ‘Dores are going to get most of the national support merely because they are a perennial doormat of the SEC. A lot of people feel that top teams should view Vandy as a mere gnat and not respond to them, for, once again, they are Vandy. UGA players shouldn’t be taunting Vandy players, and UGA coaches should not yell at Vandy coaches, since, apparently, Vandy is beneath us and can do no wrong. (I don’t agree, but some people do.)
If UGA were playing Alabama and this exact scenario happened, things would be different…
Second, Richt can’t win in this scenario at all. Richt keeping his calm and cool is, oddly enough, exactly what people are saying Grantham should have done; however, many view his demeanor and listen to his comments and equate this with agreement with Franklin. Richt was merely trying to let Franklin, the instigator, mouth off and let off steam. Richt didn’t know all the facts, so he let Franklin vent and walked off the field to deal with it as he saw fit. What’s wrong with that? Just because Richt didn’t fly off the handle in support of Grantham, Williams, or anyone else doesn’t mean Richt thinks what Grantham did was terrible and/or expected.
But had Richt flown off the handle…
See my first reason above…it’s Vandy. Had Richt become irate and incensed, he would have been lambasted for the same reasons Grantham is. Plus, what good comes out of Richt sticking up for Grantham at that point? Nothing, for, as we all know, Franklin was trying to push buttons to make a statement that Vandy won’t back down from anyone, and a confrontation between Richt and Franklin would only have escalated into something worse. Thus, Richt did all that he could to calm everyone down…and he’s getting raked over the coals for it.
Beat Florida, and no one will talk about the Vandy game anymore…
"Don't go ninja'n nobody that don't need ninja'n!" ~ Kung Fu Hillbilly.
by Jman781 on Oct 19, 2011 10:19 AM EDT reply actions 2 recs
I agree.
But most people don’t take the time to actually watch Vandy games or review statistics. This Vandy team is much tougher than previous squads, but I’ve seen countless comments, articles, etc. with this as the main argument as to why UGA’s actions were deplorable:
“But they’re VANDY…”
Vanderbilt is absolved of all wrong doing merely because they are Vanderbilt—facts and logic be damned.
"Don't go ninja'n nobody that don't need ninja'n!" ~ Kung Fu Hillbilly.
Yea, I agree with this as well, which is why I spend a lot of time watching a lot of games and reading a lot of data.
I said on a previous podcast “this isn’t the old Vandy, and I have a lot of respect for them.” It’s surprising that people took Vandy as “Vandy” when they came out of the gate 3-0. Vandy gave SC hell on D – they just couldnt convert TOs to pts.
I am absolutely, positively convinced most fans or, more importantly, a lot of the media, just report on the reporting without actually watching games or doing background work. It’s why I wrote a post on how the national perception of Coach Richt is quite different than bulldogs may have. I have a Big 12 coworker that swears CMR will be fired. And this isnt an uncommon theme.
It’s also why I hope people come to dawgsports.com, listen to Kit’s podcasts, and see a bigger picture.
"The ball ain't heavy." - Herschel Walker
Once again - I wrote a post on UGA's national perception. It's simply ok to hate CMR, no matter what the facts are.
"The ball ain't heavy." - Herschel Walker
































