SB Nation Atlanta Editor's Pick
"We're Not That Far Away"
"We're not that far away."
I must have heard it a dozen times on the postgame radio show with Jeff Dantzler and David Greene. It's the ambiguous, naïve, oft-declared mantra that programs and their supporters turn to in low times. It's a way of reassuring ourselves that we aren't that bad. You know - a couple of bounces go our way, a few bad flags get picked up, a few good flags get thrown, and this season wouldn't have been so endlessly dour. It reeks of self-pity and foolish optimism. Now, I'm hearing it in regard to my beloved Georgia Bulldogs.
We're not that far away.
I suppose that's true. Those highly valued recruiting rankings suggest we don't lack talent. We send a bevy of top quality players to the NFL - often in the first round of the draft - every year. At no point this season were we shellacked in the manner some of our previous, more highly regarded teams have been. So all signs would point to us being "not that far away." As such, the question arises: If we're not that far away, what the hell is keeping us from getting there?
The old states of the Confederacy have become the mecca of college football, darlings of primetime television and mainstream media. The best players want to come to the South because that's where the best programs and the most exposure reside; such is the era of satellite television and signing bonuses for NFL draftees. Teams with sterling national perceptions such as Alabama, Florida, Auburn, and LSU will always be stocked with talent, while overflow will occasionally stock the cupboards of a Mississippi State, a South Carolina, or an Arkansas. This means that Georgia, with its own perpetually full cupboard, will never have an easy path to success.
But the tools are there, or so we're told. After all, we're not that far away. If the issue isn't the tools, it is the craftsman. In his later years, my grandfather, a carpenter, would look at his jig saw in disgust, wondering why it didn't give him a clean line. He didn't realize it was the Parkinson's until he could no longer drive straight on the road.
Look, I'm not advocating the firing of Mark Richt. Over the time he's been with the program, I've become a young man and grown to love the Bulldogs more than any team in any sport; that's due largely to the brilliant success he had with the team for seven years. But the past three years have been woeful, a precipitous fall from lofty heights blindsiding all of Bulldog Nation. And with the way this conference is, it only takes one year to go from "not that far away" to "Damn, that's a long way off".
That's the hard truth of the situation. Almost every team in the SEC is "not that far way". It's going to take Mark Richt finding something within himself that he has lost, getting rid of something that he has added (Mike Bobo), or Greg McGarity starting from scratch. And that has to happen soon because whatever it is that isn't far away is not a static thing; it is moving and we are being left behind.
26 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think that's a fair assessment...
… though I would say the past 2 years and not the past 3. 2008 was a disappointing season because of the expectations we had going in, but it was still a 10-win season and we still finished in the top 10 in the polls. We can agree to disagree on that point, however, because that’s not really the argument I’m going to try to support.
The biggest problem we’ve had over the past 2 years, but especially in 2010, is that we’ve lost the ability to win close games.
The biggest hallmark of Mark Richt-coached teams has been that they pull through in the clutch and win games decided by less than 7 points. The hobnailed-boot game in 2001, the Alabama and Auburn games in 2002, and practically every game against South Carolina are a few examples of this effect, but ultimately there was a confidence (I’m not going to use the “swagger” cliche) among the players that no matter what happened, they were going to find a way to either make a defensive stop or an offensive drive to win the game.
I don’t think Mark Richt has lost the ability to motivate players, and I don’t think Mike Bobo randomly gained then lost (then regained) the ability to create and execute an effective game plan in 2009 and 2010. I think the problem is with on-field leadership.
The biggest problem is that I don’t know how to fix it. Leadership is more of an intangible asset. You can try to recruit kids that have some leadership potential, combined with the talent that will fit your system, combined with the academics that will allow them to meet the NCAA guidelines… but how can you ensure that a 17 or 18-year-old will become an effective on-field leader when they’re 20 or 21 years old?
Ultimately, I agree that Mark Richt is accountable for the results his program achieves, both on an off the field. The thing that concerns me most is: a) I like Mark Richt, and b) If this is the problem, I have no idea how to fix it.
And that last point is what’s so tricky about this…. Richt is the only one to take us to great national prominence during my lifetime, and I adore him for that… But if he can’t get us back there, when is it acceptable to jettison him and his staff? The trick is to give him the time he’s earned, but not let the program get this unwashable stink on it that will keep recruits away as well as top flight coaches who don’t want to rebuild a program in utter shambles. We’re not in utter shambles yet, but we’re not that far away.
I’m just glad I don’t have to make the decision.
Walter Cronkite wasn’t known as Kid Cronk for a fucking reason.
"Unfortunately, it won’t shut anyone up, but if (the Falcons) get a Lombardi, I’m going to spend all of 2011 not giving a rat’s ass what anyone says." – Dave Choate
Good question
In any job I think you jettison when you no longer think the person can get up to speed. To some degree anyone is going to have some learning to do on the job. Because of that it’s important to see how the person deals with problems and whether they can successfully adapt, or if he can’t adapt and you have to let him go.
The thing with Richt is that he met with such initial success that I think it gave him a false sense of security and caused him to resist change. And probably fans forgot that when we hired Richt he had never been a head coach, never had to fire anyone, and never had been the one with whom the buck stops. Also I think it may be easier getting players’ attention when you’re the new sheriff in town.
But Richt did finally make changes and as I sit here today I want to see what becomes of our defense in year 2 with Grantham et al. I’m also looking forward to seeing if Tereshinski is in fact the antichrist to Richt’s nice guy. And finally I want to get the 2011 recruiting class in school; unlike Buck Belue I think we’re going to see a lot of new faces next year taking significant snaps.
by South FL Dawg on Jan 3, 2011 12:40 AM EST up reply actions
And probably fans forgot that when we hired Richt he had never been a head coach, never had to fire anyone, and never had been the one with whom the buck stops. Also I think it may be easier getting players’ attention when you’re the new sheriff in town.
That’s spot on. Excellent point!
On a side note, for all the complaining about the job Stacy Searles has done with the OL, if UAB hadn’t come along we’d likely still have Neil Callaway. I’m conflicted about the implications of this.
"I want anything wearing red and black to tear the head off anything that isn't." - Lewis Grizzard
But I think one thing that is essential
Is that the program and its supporters must either go all in to fix what we have now or bite the bullet and start over. It will not be easy and it has to be done with fire. We can’t just say “oh, we’re not as bad as our record” and hope that next year a few more bounces go our way. We have to make our own luck, and we can’t be content with being “close to good.”
Walter Cronkite wasn’t known as Kid Cronk for a fucking reason.
"Unfortunately, it won’t shut anyone up, but if (the Falcons) get a Lombardi, I’m going to spend all of 2011 not giving a rat’s ass what anyone says." – Dave Choate
2005 had that absolute joke of a Sugar Bowl chokefest.
2006 sucked too.
2007 had two ruinous, idiotic loses early to SC and Tenn.
2008 had a team that believed its own hype and choked at almost every opportunity.
2009 was a disaster.
2010 was a forest fire.
Sorry, but its not just “the last 2 years.”
It is basically the last 5+.
I just talked to Mark Richt, and he said he is sorry he hasn't gone 14-0 every season.
I also contacted the 110 or so teams that also haven’t won a NC in the last 10 years, and they feel CMR should be fired too.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
Nicely written Mr Pace.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
thanks, tankertoad
I think I wrote this all in my head while listening to the postgame show… I’m amazed it lasted through the damage I did to my brain cells on NYE…
Walter Cronkite wasn’t known as Kid Cronk for a fucking reason.
"Unfortunately, it won’t shut anyone up, but if (the Falcons) get a Lombardi, I’m going to spend all of 2011 not giving a rat’s ass what anyone says." – Dave Choate
This is a fine post
and you have articulated much of what I am thinking. Kudos.
"If we score, we may win. If they never score, we'll never lose."
-Erk Russell
Nice write up...
I think we aren’t that far off from either extreme. We have the talent to be very good, very soon. We also are very close to becoming Ole Miss/Miss St (before Mullen) bad, and by that I mean we slink around at 5-7, 6-6, 7-5 with the occasional good season every 10 years or so. I have been an ardent supporter of CMR over the past two years because of his track record. That being said one of my biggest frustrations with the Donnan years was the fact that we had a ton of talent but consistantly looked completely unprepared and were outcoached on game day. When CMR first arrived I remember making the comment “Well we may not win every week, but at least we won’t be outcoached or come out unprepared to play”. I am not sure that we don’t need a change for the sake of change (i.e. new voices, a new method of preparation). I have to admit that I am struggling with whether to send in my Hartman Fund contribution next month. With the contribution + tickets I am spending $1000+ to watch a sub par product….I can think of a lot of things to use $1000 on other than bad football.
Two Faced Janus
I am definitely in the raving flip-flipper camp myself, so I agree with your cogent post. However, let me point out a couple of items of evidence on the hopeful side of the scales. First, we were not simply flattened in any game this year, as we were twice last year (UT, UF) and previous (UA, UF) and once even in ‘07 (UT); we were in every game, including AU. Second, despite occasional baffling play calls (20+ yards and send our RB between the tackles TWICE in a bowl game?) and a mediocre running game (mounting evidence that McClendon coaches his guys down), we’ve had an offense that produces a lot of points. I don’t believe in quick fixes, but a stud RB and genuine commitment to disciplined S&C would go a looooong way.
We have heard the same excuses for several years now
We will hear players this off-season talk about how we needed leaders…much like the last 2 years
We will hear coaches talk about improving….like the last 2 years
We will hear about how our strength and conditioning this off-season WAS INCREDIBLE…like the last 2 years
All talk…Richt is out of true ammo
So what will it take....
….to close the gap from where we are and where we should be? We all praise Coach Richt the man. We believe that the fanbase’s relationship with Coach Richt is not like that of a mob boss with his prize assassin , and that Coach Richt would not use medical scholarships to clear spots on the roster. But the coaches who do that have three of the last 4 MNC’s. Over the past few weeks we have learned about the rigid drug policy that UGA has in place relative to other SEC schools potentially places the Dawgs at a competitive disadvantage. Caleb King ran afoul of one of the strictest academic support policies in the SEC. Not to mention the oversigning that most everyone else in the SEC engages in.
Coach Richt and AD McGarity along with the fan base recognizes the need for change. Like many others, I am uncertain if Coach Richt can carry out this change. While we may not like how Urban Meyer and Nick Saban run their programs, they win and they had their teams prepared to play yesterday (Nick Saban impressively so).
It appears, for better or worse, that a coach needs to have a bit of ruthlessness to do well in the SEC nowadays. Does Mark Richt have that? We shall see.
It does seem that way...
While I loathe the notion of bringing in Mike Leach as some have suggested, locking people in an electrical closet does wreak of ruthlessness. Now if we could just recruit the child of an ESPN analyst…
"I want anything wearing red and black to tear the head off anything that isn't." - Lewis Grizzard
It took Urban Meyer one year to go from 13-1 to 8-5...
…and Nick Saban’s boys basically did the same thing this year we did in 2008—go from preseason number one to 10-3. I’m not saying that Richt shouldn’t change things up, but it’s a little unfair that everyone keeps comparing his current difficulties with coaches who haven’t stayed in one place long enough to see how their coaching prowess stands the test of time.
Will
by wqueenjr on Jan 3, 2011 10:02 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Rec'd for sanity.
Unfortunately, SEC football is not a sane world. But you’re 100% right, wqueenjr.
by vineyarddawg on Jan 3, 2011 11:36 AM EST up reply actions
Daring to go where no man has gone before...
That was the first sentence ever written by mankind to include both “sterling national perception” and “Auburn”.
And may well be the last.
Well played.
Touche
But outside of the South, everyone pretty much only sees a team that’s had two undefeated seasons in the same decade, in the vaunted SEC.
Walter Cronkite wasn’t known as Kid Cronk for a fucking reason.
"Unfortunately, it won’t shut anyone up, but if (the Falcons) get a Lombardi, I’m going to spend all of 2011 not giving a rat’s ass what anyone says." – Dave Choate
It's about mental toughness and heart
A lot of people are searching for what’s wrong with Georgia’s team. Let me provide two possible areas for concern.
1. Mental toughness: On two separate ocassions this year Bacarri Rambo stated publicly the defense was not mentall tough enough. They weren’t tough enough to be in the right position when they needed to make a play and when things looked bad they gave up. You can’t be a SEC Championship team if you’re not mentally tough.
2. Heart: If we have the talent some think we do, then they didn’t show it. I saw guys giving up on a regular basis this year. You can’t be a SEC Championship team if you’ve got no heart.
Boys, we have an identity crisis within the Georgia program. Are we Bobby Bowden’s FSU program of the ’90’s (finesse), or are we a power SEC team? When we hired Searles we tried to move away from the FSU finesse game to a more power oriented attack. What we got was a little bit of both and the results are there for everyone to see. Bama’s offense is even more predictable than Bobo’s, the problem for us is Bama has the personnel to run that type of power run oriented offense to perfection. UGA seems like a confused hybrid, with a weak undersized offensive line that can not run block and only provides marginal holes for our RB’s to get through.
Quite frankly, I don’t place a lot of hope that Mark Richt can turn this thing around with the type of players we have today. We are short on talent and long on bad attitudes. I hope Richt can make us all look like fools with our predictions of doom and gloom, but I’m not betting the mortgage on it.
One thing nobody mentioned...
Lack of discipline! When a team has this many arrests every year, and a top round pick sells his jersey, and key running backs are declared academically ineligible before a bowl game, etc., etc., discipline is an issue…and to win in football, discipline is the number 1 component in championship teams!! Bear Bryant didn’t have #1 recruits every year, but AJ Green would have been booted off his team. Players must depend on each other, bond a brotherhood, and focus on discipline to win, regardless of talent. If I am wrong, explain Mississippi State’s rise. When was the last time anyone ever seen Mississippi State blow out Michigan in the past 50 years?? I didn’t see any arrests or high profile players getting sacked by the NCAA for doing something stupid!!! If Mark Richt is to carry Georgia to a championship team, he must impose discipline at all levels!!
but AJ Green would have been booted off his team
Absolutely no way. Bear Bryant didn’t have the same constraints with scholarships and the NCAA. He also didn’t have 24/7 news and the internet to deal with. I don’t even think we can accurately say how Bear would have handled things. But he damn sure wouldn’t have kicked off his star receiver.
"One thing I will never do as long as I’m at Georgia is lose to Florida." - Herschel Walker
Not to mention
That AJ Green would have been booted off of zero of the “disciplined” teams that have been National Champions.
"I want anything wearing red and black to tear the head off anything that isn't." - Lewis Grizzard
You do know, of course,
that Bear came VERY close to axing Joe Namath…not once, but twice. He did, however suspend him for the SUGAR BOWL in 1964…..there are more…many more…what about Rich Wingo? Read this excerpt from a new book coming out about the Bear….AJ Green??? He literally cost the Dawgs 2, maybe 3 more wins. Without him, teams didn’t need to double team, freeing up a safety or corner to plug any gaps, in effect cramping the running game. You may be right, but I believe AJ would have been shipped off (maybe not shipped off, in retrospect, but certainly canned for more than 4 games regardless of NCAA decisions…read this excerpt, it is the difference between Bear and Richt, which also includes winning…
“The best thing Coach Bryant did for me was kick me off the team,” said Wingo, a native of Elkhart, Ind., only 20 miles from the Notre Dame campus. "Right before my junior season, someone made the terrible mistake of voting me to be a preseason All-American, and I began to think I ‘was’ a preseason All-American.
“It was a morning practice and we were in linebacker drills, where Coach (Brother) Oliver would throw one of us the ball and we’d sprint off the field. I’m sure I wasn’t hustling, although I certainly wasn’t consciously thinking about it. After doing that several times, Coach Bryant said, ‘Wingo, go out there and do it again.’
“That’s the first time he’d ever made me do a drill again. Everybody got completely quiet. So I got out there by myself, in a linebacker stance.
“Coach Oliver said, ‘Hut,’ he threw me the ball, and I sprinted to the sideline, and handed Coach Oliver the ball back. Coach Bryant said, ‘Do it again.’ You could have heard a pin drop. I did it again, and Coach Bryant said, ‘Get off my field.’ So I stated jogging off the field. After about 20 steps, I looked back and everybody was just staring at me. That’s when I realized I’d been kicked off the team.
“I went to the showers and my friend Tim Garl, one of the student trainers, came in and said, ‘Do you realize you’ve just been kicked off the team? No one’s ever been kicked off and allowed to come back on except Joe Namath. And you ain’t no Joe Namath.’
“I got dressed and waited for Coach Bryant after practice,” Wingo continued. "He asked me what I was doing there. I told him the last thing my dad told me before I left home years ago that no one’s going to fight for Rich Wingo any longer except for Rich Wingo. I said, ‘I’m here to fight.’
“He let me come into his office and he told me to sit down. I had been on that couch too many times – for the wrong reasons – so I sat in a chair right next to his desk. We spoke – well, he spoke – for an hour and five minutes. I’ll never forget it as long as I live. All the time he’s talking I’m thinking, ‘Am I on the team or off the team? How am I going to tell my parents?’
“So he’s leaning in his chair, smoking that Chesterfield, and he says, ‘Rich, I think you’re a good football player. And I think I am a good coach. They say you are a preseason All-American, but that doesn’t mean squat to me. I just don’t know if I want you on my football team.’ He was that blunt.
“He explained to me that I was just ‘content’ with being a starting inside linebacker and that’s the way I’d play. He said he wanted people on his team and those around him to be ‘committed’ instead of ‘content,’ people who wanted to get a little better every single day. For the first time, I realized exactly what he was talking about.
“So he put his hand on the phone and said, ‘Tell me where you want to go. You want to go home, back to Notre Dame? One phone call and you’ll be there tomorrow. Michigan? Ohio State? Back to the schools that recruited you? One phone call. As a matter of fact, if you want to stay in school here, we’ll pay your way through school. I just don’t know if I want you on my football team.
“I just sat there, not saying a word. Finally, I said, ‘Coach, this is my family. This is my fourth year. If I can’t play here, I don’t want to play anywhere.’ He looked at me and said, ’I’m going to go home and pray about it, and talk to (wife) Mary Harmon about it.’
“Then he said, “Be in my office tomorrow at 9 o’clock and I’ll tell you what I am going to do. It’ll be my decision.” I got up and left.
“That conversation impacted my life. The concept of being ‘committed’ and not ‘content’ is a major part of my testimony today. He wanted people who were totally sold out on the program. He said, ‘Rich, I’ll take people who aren’t the best athletes, but I’ll win with those guys if they are sold out every day.’ He was telling me that he didn’t think he could win with me. It just crushed me.
“So I met him in the parking lot the next morning at six a.m. He got out of the car and slammed me right off the bat. He said, “I thought I told you 9 o’clock!” I came right back at him and said, “I’ll wait.” I figured I didn’t have anything to lose.
“He said, ‘Follow me to my office.’ So I followed him up that steep coliseum stairwell. It took forever; he wasn’t the fastest walker. We got to his office, he closed the door behind us, and said, ‘Mister, if you want to be on this football team, you be on that football field today and we’ll pretend like nothing ever happened. And if you don’t, that’s fine with me. It’s your choice. Now, get out of my office and close the door.’
“I went out to practice that day thinking I’d be way down on the depth chart and would have to work my way back up. Well, I was still the starting inside linebacker, just as he said, like nothing had ever happened. Starting that day, I went from being ‘content’ to being ‘committed.’ I learned how to practice and get better every day. He took a chance on me, because he certainly had 10 guys who could have taken my place.
“All of my friends told me that after I jogged off the field that day, they had the best practice of their entire career at Alabama, because they didn’t know who was next.”

by 































