Something For All You Bumpas Hounds Out There, Another Unconventional Option, And A Warning About Premature Evaluations.
I continue to doubt that TCU's Dick Bumpas will be the next Defensive Coordinator at the University of Georgia, for a variety of reasons:
1) Doubts about how integral he is to his current team's defensive success.
2) No discernible connection to Mark Richt (except for the fact that they joined the Illuminati at roughly the same time, but you didn't hear that from me).
3) No SEC connections.
Nevertheless, Dr.B over at Shakin' The Southland, SBNation's Clemson blog, did a good summation of TCU's 4-2-5 defense before the Tigers played the Horned Frogs earlier this season.
TCU's scheme is unique for a variety of reasons, including the fact that the front seven scheme and the coverage are separated, and the coverages are actually bifurcated. That is, the free safety makes the call on one side and the rover makes the call on the other. TCU by the way beat Clem's sons 14-10, and held C.J. Spiller in check with the exception of a 60 yard reception. Even if Bumpas doesn't come anywhere near Athens, Dr.B's take is a good read if you're into x's and o's. Check it out.
Also, if you're not convinced that the next defensive coordinator will be one of the suspects widely discussed, I urge you to consider the Air Force Academy's Tim DeRuyter. His units at Air Force have been well-ranked, he's an Air Force Academy grad who actually served as a full time military coach (if you're looking for a disciplinarian) and his Mountain West experience includes scheming for the triple option, the "pistol" formation which has become more popular (especially in Tuscaloosa), and a variety of other offensive looks. His unit just got through making Houston's Case Keenum look less than Heisman-worthy.
And about the search process in general: Do I wish it were over already? Of course. But the search process has not been "disappointing" or "embarrassing" or any other similar adjective being bandied about to describe it. Why? Because with coaching searches the proof is in the pudding. It doesn't matter who turned you down, just who you ultimately get to say yes. I promise, this search is no more chaotic than any other similar search in recent years. They all look like this, but they look a lot worse from the inside. It seems a lot worse because we're thinking about our search more than we think about other schools' searches, and because we allow ourselves to consider the possibilities each candidate brings to the table. Put another way, every decent thunderstorm looks like a hurricane when you're in the middle of it without a raincoat. Hindsight has a way of adding some perspective to the experience.
Bear in mind that if Mark Richt has talked to all of the folks reported, then he is looking under all the right rocks. The fact that he wasn't able to lure Bud Foster from Virginia Tech doesn't worry me nearly as much as settling for Jon Tenuta, just because he's available to start tomorrow, would. Mark Richt doesn't have to get the best defensive coordinator in America. He just has to get a guy who's a significant upgrade. He's obviously identified folks who are. One of them will say yes.
I've been saying for 3 weeks that if we were gambling on the outcome of this, if you'd give me Kirby Smart and Todd Grantham, I'd give you the field. I still think that's a decent proposition. Smart is the one guy we know Coach Richt approached who hasn't gotten a very public pay raise and slap on the back from his current employer. That could be because Nick Saban is getting ready to coach for a title and doesn't have time for, well, you know.
Grantham looked to be available the first week of January (when Coach Richt initially said the search might be done), but now joins the rest of the Dallas Cowboys staff in the NFL playoffs. Suddenly, the search could continue through January. That could be correlation. It could be causation. I have no idea.
But I'm more than willing to peddle in rumors and speculation until we find out. Because it's interesting, intriguing, and beats the heck out of trying to figure out whether I feel more empathy for Adam James or Mike Leach. And I don't feel the least bit guilty about it. Until later . . .
Go 'Dawgs!!!
15 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
The DB coach for Air Force
is an Atlanta, GA native. If we cannot get AF’s DC, it would be awesome to get Charlton Warren.
Another guy I find interesting is Army’s co-DC, Payam Saadat. You should google him and read his background. Very fascinating guy.
I was really disappointed about whiffing on Foster
Bear in mind that if Mark Richt has talked to all of the folks reported, then he is looking under all the right rocks.
But that’s a good point. Thanks for helping keep things in perspective.
Leaving insightful football commentary and analysis to other people since 2006.
ESPN's "Rumors" page
The headline is something like “Georgia’s Defensive Coordinator vacuum may cost them with recruits.”
Thanks, WWL. Keep spreading those “rumors” that everyone already knows.
Wonder if...
“Florida’s Defensive Coordinator vacuum and Head Coach’s fickleness may cost them with recruits” will be the next head line.
TCU’s defense is awesome because of Patterson. He and Saban are the top two defensive minds in the game IMO.
by miketag on Jan 2, 2010 7:18 PM EST via mobile reply actions
MD
you just expounded greatly on what i have with brief clips been saying all along. What matters is who we get. Our judgement will come next year on the playing field. THere is no need for hurry – remember, we have 3 coaches to replace, and those three need to work well together. THere are a few more pieces in the Jinga than just “get a great DC and give him money”.
I dont buy into this costing us recruits. I realize the players on the D side of the field will spend more time with the DC than CMR, but nevertheless, as Kyle and I discussed, you never really never know the motivations of recruits. I have never (not saying it doesnt happen, but i have never heard it) heard a recruit say “i dont know who the DC is, so I am not going”. Recruits will go to a) UGA b) the program c) CMR and then perhaps other factors. Some may actually come for educational reasons! Most recruits have already made up there mind and a DC today wont change anything than a DC in 3 weeks.
"Sometimes, you just can't get rid of a bomb." - batman
The Air Force DC
This guy shut down the high power Houston team with alot less talent Richt needs to take a look at him for sure, no SEC ties but so what….Tim DeRuyter……… http://www.goairforcefalcons.com/sports/m-footbl/mtt/deruyter_tim00.html
"Disappointing" or "embarrassing"?
Anyone who has used those words to describe the DC search so far needs to keep in mind how “disappointing” and “embarrassing” Alabama’s seemingly disastrous head coach search turned out a few years ago.
Will
That's exactly the analogy I keep using
Alabama was a laughingstock for weeks until they bagged the elephant . . . but ‘Bama would have remained a laughingstock it they hadn’t bagged the elephant.
Mark Fox is a good man and he may prove to be Georgia’s Lon Kruger, paving the way to a level of relevance adequate to attract the Bulldogs’ Billy Donovan when the time comes (though I’m not holding my breath), but, after repeatedly swinging for the fences, we settled and accepted second-tier status as a ceiling.
Given the history of Georgia men’s basketball, that probably was reasonable and inevitable. Given the history of Georgia defensive coordinators in football, there is no excuse for settling. I respect and appreciate MaconDawg’s and your views upon this subject, and I certainly hope the two of you are proven right and I am proven wrong, but, right now, I’m disappointed and embarrassed that we’re still casting about for a defensive coordinator while Jimbo Fisher managed to go get Mark Stoops. I’m prepared to be pleasantly surprised, but I’m expecting the worst because expecting otherwise hasn’t worked out well for Georgia sports not coached by Suzanne Yoculan in longer than I can remember.
Go 'Dawgs!
i have to believe CMR is gettting the stars to align. if not - i can't bear to think of a waster 2010
"Sometimes, you just can't get rid of a bomb." - batman
Coach Donnan says no
I was listening to the Jim Donnan Show on 680 the fan about 3 or 4 weeks ago when this process first started and Dick Bumpas’ name first surfaced into the discussion. Coach Donnan said that Georgia fans should not want Bumpas to be Martinez’s replacement because Gary Patterson is the one calling the plays (not Bumpas).
I honestly don't know that any endorsement could mean less to me . . .
. . . from someone with discernible ties to Bulldog Nation than Jim Donnan’s word.
If Jim Donnan had the slightest idea what was good for Georgia football, Jim Donnan would be coaching Georgia football.
Go 'Dawgs!

by 















