Dawg Sports: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Baby Boilers no more: Michigan State-Purdue Preview

Paul Finebaum Hits Mark Richt With His Purse, But Doesn't Put His Weight Behind It

Permit me to begin by emphasizing that I have nothing against Paul Finebaum personally. I’ve never met the man, nor have I ever listened to his radio show. Yes, he was responsible for getting me bumped from a radio interview last week, but I made it onto the air the following day, so no harm, no foul.

In light of some of the outrageous things Finebaum has written in recent weeks---one of which led him to explain that he didn’t say Urban Meyer was a serial killer, but instead said only that he was like a serial killer---I anxiously awaited the column teased by the Mobile Press-Register on Monday. It promised that Finebaum would tell us "how fans are beginning to grow restless in Bulldogs country."

I steeled myself for the sort of over-the-top invective only Finebaum can produce. What comparisons would he draw? Would he liken Mark Richt to Ted Bundy or Caligula or Nathan Bedford Forrest? I waited with bated breath, but what I got was . . . this.

After revisiting each of the Bulldogs’ three losses last season, Finebaum concluded his second paragraph with what surely would serve as his launching pad for the inevitable excoriation, declaring: "The damage was done and fans have been grumbling ever since."

Finebaum then dived headfirst into ripping Mark Richt to shreds, saying of the aforementioned grumbling:

The sound has not been thundering or unremitting, but it has been enough to make some key followers of the program wonder if a small problem couldn't lead to a bigger one down the road for Richt, whose name has never been synonymous with hotseat.

What?!?! All right, so there’s been some "grumbling" . . . but it hasn’t "been thundering," nor has it been "unremitting"? Well, in any case, there’s been some grumbling, just of the quiet and occasional sort. Anyway, the grumbling has been sufficient to . . . hold on, what was that again?

The sound has not been thundering or unremitting, but it has been enough to make some key followers of the program wonder if a small problem couldn't lead to a bigger one down the road for Richt, whose name has never been synonymous with hotseat.

See there? We have a problem. Admittedly, Finebaum acknowledges that it’s "a small problem," but it’s making people question and doubt and declare that . . . actually, it’s just making people "wonder" whether it "couldn’t lead to" another problem.

Soon, perhaps? Well, no, "down the road." Does this leave Coach Richt imperiled? Well, no, his "name has never been synonymous with hotseat." If that passage had been any more equivocating, noncommittal, and watered down with caveats and qualifications, we college football fans would have needed Slate’s William Saletan to declare it the Finebaumism of the Day.

What followed was a halfhearted and superficial paint-by-numbers rundown of the challenges facing the Georgia program. The Bulldogs sometimes have discipline issues . . . although Mark Richt deals with these effectively and this offseason has featured notably few off-field incidents. The Bulldogs have trouble beating Florida . . . as do other top-tier SEC programs. The Bulldogs face many challengers on a daunting schedule . . . as historically has been the case. The Bulldogs must compete with many high-profile programs in recruiting . . . an arena in which they are doing just fine.

Lest we be left to wonder whether Paul Finebaum went on vacation for a few days and left his kindly grandmother to pen this halfhearted effort, the fire-breathing pot-stirrer threw in this peroration:

And if you don't think Georgia fans can fall completely out of love with Richt, Tommy Tuberville and Phillip Fulmer have plenty of time on their hands right now to tell you how it's done.

Of course, falling out of love with your coach requires first that you at one point fell in love with him, and, while Phillip Fulmer and Tommy Tuberville certainly were respected at their respective institutions, neither ever was the object of as much affection as Mark Richt. Indeed, many of us on the outside looking in commented on the apparent lack of affection many Tennessee fans had for Coach Fulmer and many Auburn fans had for Coach Tuberville, in light of their resumes of achievement.

Bill King deftly dealt with Finebaum’s last lame attempt at animadversion when he wrote:

I realize that in the state where Finebaum works the fan bases tend to have a love/hate relationship with their coaches; they either elevate them to sainthood or start sending projectiles through their windows at the first sign of trouble.

But the idea that Georgia would even consider getting rid of a 10-win-a-year coach because he hasn’t won a national championship is patently absurd.

Even if the wheels came off this year and Georgia won, say, less than eight games, Richt would not be anywhere near the so-called hot seat. . . .

Richt teetering on the hot seat? That’s about as likely as Tim Tebow breaking a sweat in the Charleston Southern game.

Precisely. Frankly, I’m disappointed in Finebaum, who made a name for himself by being the inflammatory agent provocateur of the SEC. I was looking forward to firing back in response to a snotty and irresponsible takedown. What I got instead was a second-rate attempt to offer guarded criticisms. I expected Finebaum to deliver a chop block, not an arm tackle.

Clearly, Paul Finebaum’s heart wasn’t in taking Mark Richt to task. Could it be that we actually have a head coach who is good enough at his job and decent enough as a human being that even the nastiest mad dog in the Southeast won’t bite this man?

Go ‘Dawgs!

0 recs  |  Comment 13 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Richt

I tend to agree with you I could not see Richt going anywhere, and would be really difficult to see him at any school but UGA. Of course with that said here comes the supposition on my part. Could it be possible that if Richt shows too much loyalty to someone like Willie Martinez, and does not place the program above his friendship/loyalty to his coaches that he could be ousted? I am not saying that would happen any time soon, but clearly this was a huge problem for Tuberville.

Tuberville kept too many of his cronies around and refused to replace them. It upset plenty of Auburn fans, and rightly so as they were not elite level coaches; as evidenced by the fact none of them are gainfully employed at anything resembling a BCS school. I am not quite putting Martinez in that same category, though I definitely think UGA could do a lot better. I, probably like most fans I knew thought UGA should have hired someone outside the program once Van Gorder left.

It is just that loyalty of that kind often leads to some blindness on some people’s side. Again, not trying to be too critical of Richt but it has been something I have pondered over a bit, as we all tend to do in the offseason.

by Kenny483 on Jul 22, 2009 7:44 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

If you get rid of him

Give him a plane ticket to Lexington, we’ll take those 10 wins a year.

If peeing your pants is cool, consider me Miles Davis.

by btcoop71 on Jul 22, 2009 8:09 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

That's about the best compliment I can think of

But I think we’ll keep Coach Richt and his 10 wins a year contrary to Finebaum belief. Also, if Kentucky didn’t have Rich Brooks who would we get to make fun of as the token cantakerous old man in the SEC?

http://hobnailboot.wordpress.com/

by AuditDawg on Jul 22, 2009 12:49 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Rich's favorite quote:

That’s Bullsh*t!"

Watch him say it 10 times a game.

If peeing your pants is cool, consider me Miles Davis.

by btcoop71 on Jul 22, 2009 3:07 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

He could have just as easily . . .

have substituted “Mack Brown” for “Mark Richt” and written this piece in 2002, 2003 or 2004. For all I know, he may have.

by MaconDawg on Jul 22, 2009 9:45 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Everything Finebaum said was said to get hits

But everything he said was 100% true and deep down we all know it

When last year ended, WE ALL talked about how changes HAD to be made because of how bad we played. Whenever we lose to UF, we talk about changes HAVE to be made or else. If we lose to Tech and UF again, we will hear that talk AGAIN.

If we lose to UF/Tech yet again in 2009, MANY of our fans will want his seat warm.

by AppleCub on Jul 22, 2009 10:12 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Many?

I think that depends on whether you mean in terms of raw numbers or percentages. Will there be dozens or even hundreds of folks on the internet calling for changes if we again lose to both Tech and Florida? Yes. Will it be more than 10% of season ticket holders? I personally doubt it. One of the side effects of the internet age is that the griping and grousing which used to take place at your favorite lunchtime haunt now gets spilled on the internet, and increases the perception of dissatisfaction. I’m willing to bet that a vast majority of fans, when asked who the better alternative is, would come up empty.

I also think it’s important to remember that a coach’s “approval rating”, like a politician’s, is organic. It grows and shrinks, ebbs and flows. Finebaum’s not really saying anything at all when he says “if Mark Richt doesn’t beat his rivals there will be grumbling.”

by MaconDawg on Jul 22, 2009 11:12 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

You've just made a point I've been thinking about for a long time

Anytime you see a commenter or poster that is pro-playoff they always come at you with"the vast majority of fans want a playoff of some sort and are dissatisfied with the current system". My thought is, how does the commenter define “vast majority”? If by “vast majority”, you mean that the few sites you read everyday are pro-playoff so that means everyone is pro-playoff, then I guess you’re right. There’s absolutely no way to quantify that argument or point of view.

It’s the same as when Finebaum says “sources tell me” or “I have it on authority”, but never mentions where his sources come from or whose authority he has it on. It’s a weak justification for a point of view that is not only poorly researched, but most likely false in nature.

http://hobnailboot.wordpress.com/

by AuditDawg on Jul 22, 2009 12:42 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

"sources"

I think it’s particularly telling that Finebaum described his sources as “some key followers of the program” and described their opinion as “wondering”. “Key follower”? “Wondering”? Ching’s a key follower. Hale, King (both T. Kyle and Bill), Meyer, Saban, Johnson, Spurrier, Corso, etc., might all be “key” followers of the Georgia program. That any of these people might have wondered if a small problem couldn’t lead to a bigger one down the road tells us what? Finebaum demonstrates how to write words without saying anything.

by NCT on Jul 22, 2009 1:03 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I’m willing to bet that a vast majority of fans, when asked who the better alternative is, would come up empty.

Who would be a better fit for the program? It’s an interesting hypothetical to ponder. I say you run a post about “Hypothetical, Alternate Reality Alternatives to Mark RIcht (Hypothetical Means ‘Not Real’)”, have Hinton, TSK, Hale and some others link to it, and then see how long it takes an Internet talking head to use it as evidence that we’re not satisfied.

Leaving insightful football commentary and analysis to other people since 2006.

by wwcmrd? on Jul 22, 2009 2:56 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

This gives me a headache

I long to partake this this discussion, but the mere idea of posting in this thread makes me as uneasy as a yellow jacket in a room full of Greg Blue fly swatters. So let me just state this unequivocally:

Anyone who wants to replace Mark Richt is an idiot.

There, now that that’s out of the way, I don’t believe there is a better “fit” for Georgia in the current coaching ranks than Mark Richt is. When discussing Coach Richt with other Georgia fans early in his career, I would make the following comparison to him and Georgia’s previous 3 head coaches.

Vince Dooley was a nice guy and a good coach. When he retired, Georgia fans wanted someone just like him (except with more success – at least compared to his post-1983 record). He was followed by Ray Goff, who was a great guy, but a terrible coach. Goff was followed by Jim Donnan, who was not a nice guy, but was a good (or at least fair, depending on your definition) coach. Even from Coach Richt’s first year, by comparison, you could clearly see that he was both a great guy and at least a good coach. Now, with 8 years of hindsight, I think we can say that Mark Richt is both a great guy and a great coach.

Now, I ask you, who in the head coaching ranks today would fulfill those qualifications? Certainly not Saban, Miles, or Corch Meyers, none of whom I’d classify as, “great guys.” Spurrier may have actually gone from being a bad guy and a great coach to being a good guy and a fair coach, but he’s still not both. So who? I truly think that Mark Richt is as well-suited to Georgia as Georgia is well-suited to him.

Barring the “higher calling” possiblity that was discussed in a previous thread, I think that, by the time he retires, Mark Richt will be considered the greatest coach in Georgia history… and he will have deserved it. (Of course, in today’s world, who ever really knows these things. It could all go pear-shaped, but I don’t think it will.)

by vineyarddawg on Jul 22, 2009 6:47 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Lose to Tech/UF again? Yes, i would say many both in terms

of online presense and in reality.

I doubt Season Ticket holders will revolt even with their displeasure but I would not be shocked to have many alumni tell Richt it is time to stop losing to Tech/UF yearly (assuming we lose to them again that is)

by AppleCub on Jul 22, 2009 4:19 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.
Start posting about the Bulldogs »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Uga_small
A National Signing Day Post Mortem
Uga_small
I've got a fever! And the only prescription is more Grantham : Supplementary 2010 College Signing Day Coverage
Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small
For All My Talk of Doom and Gloom . . .
Uga_small
Its the end of the world as we know it...
Small
Props to Herschel Walker
Images_small
Lets talk Jeff Owens and Geno Atkins
434477_small
How college football can learn a thing or two from soccer.
Uga_small
Warning....Warning... College Signing Day Coverage Imminent
434477_small
The only Florida blog I regularly read joins SBNation
Small
You got it right!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

Official Partner of CBS Sports