And The Nominees Are . . . Part 1.
I mentioned on Monday that I had been working on a list of possible defensive coordinator candidates, but had no intention of posting it. Even we sports bloggers (well some of us) have a basic grasp of what is and isn't a tad unseemly, and seriously proposing replacements while you still have a defensive coordinator fits the bill.
Of course, that's all irrelevant now (HT: podunkdawg). I imagine that this coaching search will be like a snowflake in Tifton. You better take some pictures to remember it, because the whole thing will be over quickly. Mark Richt wants to get a guy in place to stabilize recruiting and begin building a defensive staff. I also think there's at least a 50% chance that our new defensive coordinator will not be on this list, either in this installment or the next one. Mark Richt's M.O. in the past has been to hire solid guys who either a) none of us have heard of or b) we didn't know CMR was pursuing. That's just how the guy does business. You've been warned. So, with no further ado and in no particular order, some of the names you'll surely hear bandied about in the coming hours and days:
Kirby Smart: The fans' list seems to start here. The Georgia alum and former Bulldog assistant has helped build a solid defense at Alabama. However there have been rumors that Nick Saban keeps a tight rein on things, and that Smart might be looking to go somewhere where he can build his own identity. I don't believe it. Alabama has things rolling with a generally young team that should be very good for the foreseeable future. And few schools have proven more willing to pay top dollar for coaches than Bama. That being said, Smart currently makes $360,000 in Tuscaloosa while Willie Martinez was making a shade over $325,000 in Athens. 10 percent is not an insurmountable gap. Also keep in mind that if the rumors of Rodney Garner leaving are true, we'd also need a Recruiting Coordinator. Assuming John Lilly didn't get that post, Smart would be the perfect guy for the job. He's a south Georgia guy who's recruited the state at Georgia and Alabama.
Smart might be the ideal candidate for the job. And as an alumnus he'll certainly get a phone call, and he'll get an interview if he wants one. That being said, coaching searches are not about who you want, they're about who you can get. Even if, in Bear Bryant's words "Mama calls him home", Smart would certainly be hard-pressed to leave an ideal situation in Tuscaloosa for anything but a head coaching gig. I am fairly certain however that after the Tide defense's excellent season in 2009 and another offseason of being in demand, Smart will be receiving a tidy raise (pun totally intended). Likelihood (on a scale of 1 to 10): 6
Tommy Tuberville: He's the safe hire. A veteran SEC coach whose Auburn defenses always seemed to play above their talent level. But Tommy Tuberville would be a fool to leave the broadcasting studio at this point. He's got the folksy manner and the quick wit for it, and he'll make all the money he needs without having to pull 18 hour days and answer to yahoos (as opposed to Wahoos) like me. Mark Richt would likewise be a fool to bring in a guy who would clearly be a candidate to replace him if the defense turns around but overall results lag. As if that weren't enough, it's hard to imagine Tuberville as anything but a short term solution. He'd just be crashing on our proverbial couch until a) Steve Spurrier retires, b) Bobby Petrino gets a better offer or c) Texas A&M's cadet corps court marshals Mike Sherman. Likelihood:3
Bob Sanders: Sanders is the defensive line coach of the Buffalo Bills and the former defensive coordinator for the Green Bay Packers. He was also the guy responsible for the University of Florida defensive lines that ate a series of Georgia QB's for lunch between 1990 and 2000. Sanders is a North Carolina native and an elder statesman who preaches a "bloody street fight mentality" that seems to get results wherever he coaches. Georgia would be a nice place for him to retire from, and Sanders would be a nice guy to replace Rodney Garner if he doesn't get the nod to replace Martinez. Plus since the Bills are already making a change at the top, he could be available for interviews before other NFL assistants. If he got the job, you'd hear no argument from me. However, I don't think he has any significant ties to Coach Richt. And coaches making program-changing hires don't usually gurn things over to strangers, even highly qualified ones. Likelihood:5
Dick Bumpas: TCU Defensive Coordinator. But you folks are astute observers of the college football scene and already knew that. The Horned Frogs have been among the nation's stingiest defensive teams in recent years utilizing a base 4-2-5 alignment that brings pressure from all over the place and performs well against spread offenses. Ironically, it's not very different from the alignment Willie Martinez has utilized against Florida the last couple of years. Bumpas is an older guy who might not have a lot of aspirations of becoming a head coach. Not that I'd know for sure. I haven't had a chance to ask him. But speaking of head coaches, I have a sneaking suspicion that TCU head coach Gary Patterson may have more than a little to do with TCU's defensive schemes. If that's the case, then it wouldn't be fair to view Bumpas as a silver bullet. That being said, TCU is one team we know we can win a bidding war with. That might appeal to Damon Evans, who has been hesitant to say he'd throw cash out the Butts-Mehre windows in order to sign top assistant coaches. Likelihood: 5
Will Muschamp: Ditto the stuff I said about Kirby Smart, only with "Texas" in place of Alabama. Curiously, Muschamp is viewed as a defensive genius in some quarters of the country, but not here among his alma mater's fanbase. This is largely because his head-to-head matchups with the Bulldogs have not been terribly impressive. Muschamp is of course the head coach-in-waiting at Texas, but let's face it, if you were Mack Brown would you retire right now? Of course not. Mack Brown is making boatloads of money winning tons of football games and getting his pick of recruits from the most talent-laden state in the country. At some point you'd have to think Muschamp begins to wonder if this coach-in-waiting business is all that it's cracked up to be. I just don't think it happens quite yet. Luring Muschamp would require a similar coach-in-waiting guarantee, and Mark Richt is about 10 years too young to talk about naming a successor while maintaining a straight face. But if Coach Richt were to suddenly decide that he wants to move to Paris and study art history fulltime, this might be your guy. Likelihood: 3
Charlie Strong: Again, it's not a question of who you want but who you can get. While Georgia is in the middle of the pack in assistant coach salaries in the SEC (6th), Florida is behind us. Damon Evans has admitted that Florida is pretty much the measuring stick for the University of Georgia football program. Going after the guy who is most responsible for Florida's success in 2009 would be a powerful statement that he's committed to passing the Gators. At some point Charlie Strong will either get a head coaching position (at Louisville, for example) or give up on the notion altogether. I just don't think he's given up at this point, and sadly Florida has more cache as a waiting room than we do. Likelihood: 2
Brian Van Gorder: This one would be interesting. If you could distill all the criticisms of Willie Martinez down to one, it would be this: he's not Brian Van Gorder. Van Gorder's Atlanta defense has not exactly been burning down the Georgia Dome this season, and if Mike Smith chose to make changes he might be available. That being said, like most NFL assistants he wouldn't be available until the NFL season is over, and with Atlanta in the playoff hunt that could easily be after January 10th. I don't think Coach Richt would wait that long on anyone. This one goes under the category of interesting, but highly unlikely. Likelihood: 2
Rodney Garner: Garner was significantly the only one of our defensive coaches who was retained. One might think that gives him the inside edge to be the new coordinator. I'm not so sure. If Rodney Garner is going to be our next defensive coordinator, the fact that he hasn't yet been named as such signifies to me that he'll have to interview for the job just like everybody else. I don't know how well that will sit with Coach Garner. David Hale also recently noted Garner's somewhat unusual arrangement and apparently cuddly relationship with Damon Evans. I just don't think Garner is a lifer in Athens. He just hasn't found the right job somewhere else yet.
Also, check out David Hale's excellent wrapup of Coach Richt's afternoon teleconference on today's decision. I don't want to steal Dave's thunder, I'll just say that Coach Richt mentioned some things that you'll find telling if you read closely. Finally, I'd like to extend my personal thanks to Coaches Martinez, Jancek and Fabris. I have no reason to believe that any of them ever gave less than their absolute best to the University of Georgia and its football team. I hope that all of them move on to great things, and that they continue to have a positive influence on the lives of young men. Until tomorrow . . .
Go 'Dawgs!
0 recs |
21 comments
|
Comments
"Snowflake in Tifton", huh. I like that.
It seems Charlie is the leading candidate for the Lousiville head coaching job, and it would seem unlikely that he would turn that down. Besides that, WHY would anyone leave the Gators to come to Athens in a lateral move? I’m not convinced that Smart would be a good move period, nor that Richt wants to load up the staff with UGA alums, either Smart or Muschamp. Besides that, former Dawgs as coordinator hasn’t won the glowing approval on offense. It would seem to me that such a move would make it too easy to dump him in favor of one of them if he fails to right the ship or even if he does, if the ship rocks again in the near future.
Jujdog you can . . .
certainly borrow it. I’m just going to need it back for the title of my autobiography.
Strong
I really hope he does get the chance to be a head coach – he certainly deserves the oppotunity. We would certainly miss him, but would wish him all the success in the world. As far as losing him to ANY other team as a DC – I don’t think Meyer or Foley would ever let it happen. If it took doubling his salary, so be it.
I suspect you're correct . . .
Perversely, Strong’s leaving (which many Georgia fans have been hoping for for some time) may now hurt Georgia, because it will put us in competition for DC candidates.
I just hope they get treated with the dignity and respect they deserve on their way out
I really dread reading some of the bad things I’m sure to read from our fans as these guys leave. Obviously I don’t mean here…but there’s this place called the AJC….yeah.
Apparently Coach Richt and Sanders are buddies from the FCA circuit
I like the idea of an NFL guy, but always wonder about how they will handle the “20 hour rule.” I especially like the idea of the fresh perspective that Sanders would bring.
Also, will someone fill me in on the circumstances around Smart’s departure from UGA? I have read some things before that allude to the fact that Smart’s time here did not end amicably.
I think another big thing to come out of this will be to see how CMR handles special teams duties and his role in offensive playcalling. While the defense was certainly the most glaring issue for the last couple of years, our propensity for 3 and outs and the directional kicking have also been huge problems.
It's worth noting . . .
that Sanders was actually a college coach at Duke and Florida for longer than he’s been in the NFL. He left Florida after 2000, I believe.
Point regarding Garner
Maybe CRG wasn’t fired because he’s not technically employed by Georgia, as we have him on no contract for the year. I imagine the other three were technically under contract, so announcing their firing was the way to go, but you can’t fire someone who isn’t technically working for you.
I doubt that's the case.
The actual announcement as reported by the University’s website says that the three coaches’ contracts “were not renewed.” So, technically, they weren’t terminated… their annual contracts were simply not renewed. Unless I’m mistaken, Coach Garner has a 1-year contract just like every other assistant coach at Georgia, so we’re left to assume that his contract is currently on track to be renewed.
by vineyarddawg on Dec 2, 2009 10:56 PM EST up reply actions
I believe you are correct, sir
There was a mention somewhere in the press quotes that contract-renewal time was not here yet. I suppose it’s some time between bowl season and the beginning of spring. The comments regarding the departing coaches’ coaching through the bowl game appears consistent with this: they’re contractually obligated to do so and are welcome to do so, but will not be held to it if they want to go ahead and get the hell out of Dodge.
by NCT on Dec 3, 2009 8:18 AM EST up reply actions
Actually ...
As MaconDawg alluded to in the post, Garner is currently working without a contract.
Dean Legge at Dawg Post ($$$) submitted a Freedom of Information request for all the assistant coaches’ contracts last week. UGA reported back that Garner, in fact, didn’t have a contract.
Dadgum mouse...
… I clicked “post” instead of “preview,” like I normally do.
Even if Garner doesn’t have a contract, though, he’s still employed by the University. Most employees in most jobs do not technically have contracts… they are employed “at will” and can be terminated at any time because of it. (Now, that’s actually not the case with most athletics officials at the University, or faculty for that matter, who have tenure tracks, etc. My point is that in society at large, it’s quite common.)
I have no idea why Coach Garner wouldn’t have a contract, but since he doesn’t, he is technically able to be terminated tomorrow with no additional compensation of any kind. That would still be “firing” him, though (in reference to blackertai’s comment).
David Hale explained
Garner hasn’t signed his contract.somewhere in his discussion of Damon Evan’s philosophy. I can’t quite find it at the moment.
Yeah, I went Googling after I read that and found it on David Hale’s blog. Guess I missed that last week. Apparently, it was originally reported by Dean Legge.
by vineyarddawg on Dec 3, 2009 10:59 AM EST up reply actions
I think Smart's probability is lower than 6
“Mama called” works if it’s a promotion, or transferring to a head job, but why would he make at-best a lateral move? And here’s why I call it lateral:
We’ll pay him what he wants, give him another title if he wants it, get him in the “hot coordinator” cat bird seat, and then at the end of 2010, he’ll make the move to coach some godforsaken Sun Belt or CUSA team.
There is talent at Georgia, but I don’t see why he’d want to spend another 3-4 years trying to replicate what he’s already done at Alabama to, in essence, be where he will be in another season under Saban. Maybe I’m missing something, but there has to be more to it than alum heart-string pulling.
I don’t think this is just homerism: it just doesn’t seem logical for someone who will be in line for an HC gig in the very near future to have to build new recruiting contacts, recruit the guys for his system, then hope it bears fruit in a few seasons just because it’s home. Coaching is vagabond by nature, and, if he wants to get where he wants to be quicker, he’s better served staying put.
"Hollywood made a movie of my life. The film had me proposing to my wife on the football field. I would never misuse a football field that way." -Crazy Legs Hirsch
by Stuck in the Plains on Dec 4, 2009 6:42 PM EST reply actions
I want Bumpas...Dawgs!
For the sole reason our defense can be called the Bumpas Dawgs! (Christmas Story reference anyone?) I do hope our Bumpas Dawgs will steal more than Florida’s Christmas Turkey next year! Seasons Greetings!
I think Erk Russell could have kicked Clint Eastwood and John Wayne's butts with a corn cob and one hand tied behind his back. GATA!
Also, if you liked the subhead to this year's postgame report . . .
. . . following the win over Georgia Tech, just imagine what next year’s would look like if Dick Bumpas outdueled Paul Johnson!
Go 'Dawgs!
LOL
"Never refuse to do a kindness unless the act would work great injury to yourself, and never refuse to take a drink- under any circumstances." Mark Twain
Fair point . . .
and truthfully I placed him everywhere between 4 and 6 before settling on 6. And of course 6 on a 10 point scale is still pretty low.
But my thinking is this: Georgia may end up wanting Smart more than Bama for the simple reason that Georgia needs him more. Nick Saban has developed a network of extensive coaching contacts and could certainly replace Smart with another of his guys. Remember, Saban is a defensive guy himself, and keeps a firm hand on that unit. If we were really and truly willing to open the checkbook and borderline overpay for his services (which frankly I somewhat doubt) it could happen.
we dont need another UGA alum on staff
we need an hard nose, older, experienced, and hopefully NFL guy. The connections and pressures of the school on a alum are too much. I want an independent guy that is his own man aside from the school and isnt afraid to (privately) speak his mind.
The difference between stupidity and genius is that genius has its limits. ~ Albert Einstein

by 












