Should I Stay or Should I Go? Postmortem, Part I
Say this for Stafford and Moreno: it wasn't a tease, tease, tease. They respectfully declined comment, undertook what appears to have been a thorough investigation of the options, then decided to run for it. A few thoughts, in no particular order, mainly on the state of Georgia football in the post Moreford/Staffeno era:
- Don't sleep on Caleb King: In talking with erstwhile Dawgsports correspondent Darius Dawgberry, we both agreed that some Bulldog fans have written off King after a redshirt freshman season that was less disappointing than Mohamed Massaquoi's sophomore campaign. Massaquoi recovered to have, in this guy's opinion, one of the best 3-4 receiving seasons in Bulldog history as a senior, and will go down as a legend of the program. It's tempting to confuse lack of performance for poor performance. They are not, especially for a freshman tailback, the same thing.
- Joe Cox is not Joe Tereshinski, III: But I'm not saying he's D.J. Shockley, either. Shockley had far more significant gameday experience than Cox at the same point in his Bulldog career. Joe Cox however is the same guy who led the comeback against Colorado in 2006. He's been very impressive since he got to Athens, but he's been behind a guy he was just never going to pass. My guess at this point is that we'll see a lot of Joe Cox and a bit of Logan Gray in 2009 unless one of the true freshmen is absolutely astonishing. Cox does however desperately need a nickname (more on that at the bottom).
- Richard Samuel is not moving to linebacker: This may be one of those predictions that I later regret, but I just don't see it. I think he showed too much promise late in the season, especially as a blocker. I also think a two back set with King and Samuel makes all the sense in the world, especially behind an offensive line that will be loaded for bear. Perhaps the main reason Samuel won't move is that we have far more proven linebackers than proven tailbacks. That's no small consideration.
- A.J. Green will break Terrance Edwards' receiving yards record in 2009: Imagine how many yards MoMass would have gone for this season if A.J. Green's nagging groin and hamstring issues had forced him to redshirt. While I am supressing flashbacks to Fred Gibson's sophomore campaign, I don't think A.J.'s season was a fluke. As the primary target in an offense that's still looking for a reliable tight end receiving threat, dependable supporting wide receivers and a clear #1 tailback, Green will be the main target behind an offensive line that should give our quarterback (whoever that guy is) more time to throw than Matt Stafford enjoyed in 2008.
- Mike Moore will help. A lot. Some guys just come into their own later than others. Mike Moore has finally found his niche as this offense's Reggie Brown. The physical receiver who'll go across the middle on the slants. Who'll turn an 8 yard out route into 12 yards. I really like what I've seen from him this season. Mike Moore knows what to do and he's confident he can do it. In the long run, I think his performance is actually more important to our passing game next season than A.J. Green's. Because Green will get his yards. But without a viable second option, our passing game just doesn't hum.
- Matt Stafford is neither a disappointment nor a failure: I thought this might be a separate post all by itself. And I'm sure it will generate some comments. While Stafford will not be remembered as fondly as David Greene, few other red and black quarterbacks have. In the end, the guy did set the school record for touchdown passes in a season. His 27-7 career record as a starter is among the best in University history. And he led the Bulldogs to a #2 national ranking. The fact that he struggled behind a patchwork offensive line, and alongside a defense that sometimes just didn't show up skews the perception a little. As does the fact that he really had nowhere to go but down. I mean, when you spark your own demographic trend, it's all downhill from there.
- Mark Richt may just give up redshirting: This season Coach Richt played every true freshman who wasn't on crutches or stricken with leprosy. He now realizes that, as the old expression goes, they grow up so fast. And after three years they become draft eligible, no matter what. It's interesting to think of what Knowshon could have done as a true freshman in that injury-plagued 2006 backfield, but we'll never know. That's a mistake you won't see Coach Richt make again. The proof was on display this season in the person of A.J. Green. While Israel Troupe and Kennth Harris might have held down the fort, Coach Richt and Coach Eason played the freshman, and it paid dividends. That won't be the last time we see a true freshman get on the field while the getting's good. I'll be back later this week to look at life from Stafford and Moreno's perspectives. Until then, note that the sun rose this morning, and the birds are singing. Life will go on, though with less dancing and keg lifting. And no frosting guns, which is kind of a bummer.
Go 'Dawgs!!!
0 recs |
14 comments
Comments
Some of these may not be appropriate for the kids...
Political/current events: “Joe the Quarterback”
Political/non-current events: “Senator McCarthy and the Red Scare”
Simpsons: “Flaming Joe’s”
Spurrier inspired: “Cox and Fire”…optional “Cox and Firecrotch”
Montana inspired: “Joe Cool”
Namath inspired: “Broadway Joe”
Stafford inspired: “Carolina Coxlinger”
Personally, I think “The Red Scare” would work, if that baby-faced kid actually scared folks.
by Tiller on
Jan 8, 2009 2:22 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I agree...
about not sleeping on King. I’ve been impressed with King’s running ability. He’s able to make some yards when nothing was there. He catches the ball well out of the backfield and has a nice burst. He’s got to improve on his blocking though or he’ll be riding the bleacher express again.
Also on the redshirting. CMR will give a lot more consideration into the kids he redshirts. I’ve been chastised on other sites for saying this but how many of the elite players coming out of high school are really planning on staying through their senior year? During their recruitment they’re considering the school(s), which gives them the best chance to make it to the pros (see Terrell Pryor). Now I’m not suggesting they’re leaving after their 3 years no matter what but it’s not like they have to be top 5 or 1st round anymore. Nor am I suggesting to never redshirt another player again but if you have a difference maker (a.k.a. AJ Green, Julio Jones) you probably should go ahead and play’em while you have’em.
by deanpat92 on
Jan 8, 2009 2:37 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I actually think UGA will look a lot like the Bama team of this year
A smart veteran (even though Cox hasn’t played all that much) game manager at QB, a duo RB system, a veteran O-line and a pretty solid defense. I think Richt leaned on the two headed beasts too much sometimes. Now its time to play smart, effecient football.
When you are an Alabama fan you are expected to hate Auburn, I hate Tennessee because I want to.
by bammer on
Jan 8, 2009 3:13 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
good points bammer . . .
Joe Cox really knows our offense as well as anybody. And that offensive line will allow him some breathing room. I’m sort of hoping to see Chapas, Samuel and King back there in the power-I, but that’s just because I love a brand of football that could be called “neanderthal ball”.
But I think a lot of it for us is going to come down to the defense (the blogger typed, cringing noticably).
by MaconDawg on
Jan 8, 2009 3:36 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I'm with you on that
I’d love to see us turn around and hand the ball off 40 times a game out of the power-I. I enjoy nothing more in football than a good ground game.
http://hobnailboot.blogspot.com/
by AuditDawg on
Jan 8, 2009 3:39 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
The running game is even more important these days
with the new clock rules…Why do you think we (bama) were so good at jumping on people and then riding the clock….When are consistently making drives of 7-8-9-minutes…the gmes is shortened and possessions are minimized…but why am i telling you guys that? Yall are smart fellas
When you are an Alabama fan you are expected to hate Auburn, I hate Tennessee because I want to.
by bammer on
Jan 8, 2009 3:55 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Yeah . . .
I dimly remember somebody doing that to us this year in Athens. But I can’t recall who. I pretty much blocked it out as a coping mechanism.
by MaconDawg on
Jan 8, 2009 4:02 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I wish Moreno and Stafford the best. I’m disappointed, but what can you do? That being said, I really hope Cox can stand up and take the leadership reins, which in my opinion Stafford did not. I think Stafford did a great job with numbers, but it takes much more than that to be a good quarterback. As much as I HATE the Gators, they have a true leader in Tebow and I wanted so much to see that kind of itensity from Stafford. Cox has promised this, now all HE has to do is deliver the numbers.
by mamadawg on
Jan 8, 2009 4:24 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I voted for "The Ginger Assassin"...
…but I actually like “The Ginger Balla” (suggested by someone on Georgia Sports Blog) better. And if you haven’t yet, cruise over to Hale’s blog to read some of Cox’s post-Staff comments. Sounds like he’s planning on being a balla.
by wqueenjr on
Jan 8, 2009 6:24 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Cox
The Red Zeplin!
If I had my way, I'd give a coconut to everyone.
by Jojadog on
Jan 8, 2009 6:25 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
If we're going to go that route . . .
. . . why not “The Grateful Red”?
Go 'Dawgs!
by T Kyle King on
Jan 8, 2009 7:57 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Sturdivant and Owens.
Having them back is huge. Keeping them healthy is huger. Or something like that.
Abolish directional kicking.
by DavetheDawg on
Jan 8, 2009 9:04 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I just saw the Big 12's conference ad . . .
. . . and it crystallized for me what was wrong with this Georgia team.
The Big 12 doesn’t brag about Oklahoma, Texas, or Texas Tech. It brags about Sam Bradford, Colt McCoy, Graham Harrell, and Michael Crabtree.
That’s all well and good in, say, track and field or swimming, where individuals are performing as individuals, but football is a team sport. It isn’t about the best individual player, it’s about the players that perform best as a team.
I believe Matthew Stafford and Knowshon Rockwell Moreno were team players. They certainly were more about winning games than about individual honors. However, too many of our wins were about individuals: Stafford had a good game; Moreno had a good game; A.J. Green had a good game. How often did the team have a good game?
Please don’t misunderstand me; I’m very sorry Stafford and Moreno are gone, and I wish them well. Heck, I’ll actually be rooting for the N.F.L. teams that draft them next year. (My pro football rooting interests are entirely about how many former Bulldogs are on the squad; the year the Falcons went to the Super Bowl, I was the only guy at the party I attended who was rooting for the Broncos, because they had Terrell Davis.) They both played with genuine heart and grit, in addition to talent, and I will always be grateful to them for it, but there’s a difference between playing inspired football and playing inspiring football.
The silver lining to their departures is that the other players will know they can’t rely on a single superstar to step up and get it done; they will have to play together as a team.
Tim Tebow is one of the best players we’ve ever seen, but, when Florida relied totally on Tebow last year, they lost four games. This year, they’ve played as a team, with many supremely talented parts performing together as a unified whole . . . and look where they are right now, at halftime of the national championship game. That is what the ’Dawgs have to do in 2009.
Go 'Dawgs!
by T Kyle King on
Jan 8, 2009 10:08 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I can't help but note that . . .
“The Ginger Assassin” has taken an early and convincing lead. I’m a little surprised.
by MaconDawg on
Jan 9, 2009 11:00 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs








