Why Georgia's Question Marks in the Kicking Game Are a Blessing in Disguise
I take a back seat to no man where respect for Paul Westerdawg is concerned. I have been giving the proprietor and lead author of the Georgia Sports Blog credit for being the Chuck Yeager of the Dawgosphere since, quite literally, the day Dawg Sports debuted.
However, Paul and I see it differently when it comes to the importance of Blair Walsh. Expressing his concern about the No. 1 kicker on the Bulldog depth chart, Paul remarked:
Speaking as a guy whose height and weight almost exactly mirror the height and weight at which Billy Bennett was listed in the Georgia media guide his senior year, I am a huge fan of the kicking game. If anything, I probably overemphasize the importance of special teams in my assessment of a particular team or a given game.
For once, though, I’m actually a little pleased that the kicking game is an area of uncertainty for the Red and Black. Don’t get me wrong; I don’t want us to be bad on special teams, any more than I want the ‘Dawgs to be bad at anything, anywhere, ever.
However, I see the potential benefits inherent in Mark Richt not having a Rex Robinson, a Kevin Butler, a Billy Bennett, or a Brandon Coutu on the sideline.
Ever since Coach Richt turned the play-calling duties over to Mike Bobo, we have seen an already outstanding Georgia head coach take it to a new level. Starting with the on-side kick---against Virginia Tech, no less!---in the 2006 Chick-fil-A Bowl, Mark Richt has been a bolder coach, reversing the typical evolution of most head honchos by starting out conservative and becoming more of a riverboat gambler over time.
When a coach has a Billy Bennett or a Brandon Coutu at his disposal, fourth and two at the opponent’s 32 yard line is a no-brainer; it’s like having a two-run lead heading into the top of the ninth and having Joshua Fields in the bullpen.
Here’s the thing, though: I don’t want Mark Richt to think fourth and two at the opponent’s 32 yard line is a no-brainer. I want Mark Richt to look at the spot of the ball and look at the uprights so tantalizingly far away and look at the flag flapping in the breeze and wonder, just a little, just for a second.
In that moment, I don’t want him to know with certainty: "My guy’s money from 49 yards, so the smart thing to do is take the points." It’s O.K. if he thinks that; it’s O.K. if he believes that; I just don’t want him to know that, because I want him to have to pause just long enough to think: "Three points isn’t a sure thing."
In that moment, I want Evil Richt to say, "You know what? We don’t have Billy Bennett or Brandon Coutu, but we’ve danged sure got Knowshon Moreno, Matthew Stafford, and nine other guys that didn’t just drive the length of the field hoping to come away with three points. The heck with it; we’re going for it."
Please don’t misunderstand me: I wish Blair Walsh all the best, I will be cheering for him to succeed, and I have every confidence that he will turn out to be the latest in a long line of successful Georgia kickers.
I just want Blair Walsh to be the best dadgum extra-point kicker in the country.
A reliable kicking game is a fine thing, but, to the extent that the slightest twinge of doubt about our placekicking serves to discourage complacency and promote gutsy decisionmaking by a head coach whose bold calls have paid big dividends since the temporary downturn in the middle of the 2006 season, I believe what Paul Westerdawg identifies as a minus might be transformed into an enormous plus.
If the thought of two or three games coming down to the leg of a freshman kicker results in this supremely talented Georgia team being led into battle by a gunslinging Mark Richt with his hand at his holster and the safety off, I not only don’t find that prospect scary; I find it downright invigorating.
If that’s the deal being put before me, then hand me a pen, ‘cause I am ready to sign on the line that is dotted.
Go ‘Dawgs!
0 recs |
11
comments
Read Related
Comments
I agree
I think Bobo probably has the same thought process as you do which will hopefully result in 7-14 point wins vs. 1-3 point losses. Go dawgs
by andersondawg on Jul 9, 2008 8:11 AM EDT 0 recs
C'mon
4th and 2 at the opponent’s 32 should be Moreno Time this year even if you still had Coutu, unless you’re already up big. And let’s not forget, a certain recent Florida team had its kicker go 4-13 in the regular season and it still won the national championship.
I agree that it may not be as big a deal as you think. Then again, I’m also potentially staring down the barrel of having a true freshman kicker, so perhaps it’s just rationalizing.
by Year2 on Jul 9, 2008 8:28 AM EDT 0 recs
I'm trying to look at this positively . . .
really I am, but I keep coming back to this nightmare vision of a true freshman kicker on the road at LSU in the waning moments of a close game. Quick, somebody toss me a Rolaids.
by MaconDawg on Jul 9, 2008 10:06 AM EDT 0 recs
Or you could flashback to Wes Byrum in the Swamp last year, a freshman kicker who essentially kicked two game winning field goals in a row in just as tough an environment. It can be done.
by Year2 on
Jul 9, 2008 11:56 AM EDT
up
0 recs
I've thought of that Year2 . . .
I even went back and watched the tape of that game. I still have a vague but palpabe sense of foreboding. But watching Urb get kicked in the shorts by a freshman kicker (again) was a nice little offseason present. I also went back and watched the Cocktail Party again. Timmy Ballgame’s tears were just as sweet the second time around :)
Totally unrelated, but is Dee Finley going to get into school this year? I thought he was going to be an instant impact guy in the Florida secondary last season.
by MaconDawg on
Jul 9, 2008 12:42 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Finley
Dee Finley was a high school senior last year, and he’s academically ineligible for this Fall. He’s apparently going to prep school for a semester or two to get his grades up. As long as there are no injuries, Florida will be fine with Major Wright, Dorian Munroe, and Will Hill at safety. Having Finley would have been nice though.
Re: last season, did you mean Jerimy Finch? He broke his leg against Tennessee, got a medical redshirt, and is now transferring to Indiana because of personal and academic reasons.
by Year2 on
Jul 9, 2008 1:08 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Year2 . . .
Worse than having the wrong guy, I apparently have lost touch with the space/time continuum. I meant Finley but for some reason typed “last” rather than “this”. I’m also a little surprised that Will Hill’s not playing LB.
by MaconDawg on
Jul 9, 2008 5:28 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Don’t worry about it.
Regarding Hill, he was promised in recruiting that he’d get to play safety, so that’s where he starts. Florida is actually well-stocked at linebacker for the moment, the only place on the defense you can say that.
by Year2 on
Jul 9, 2008 7:58 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Kicking game
I agree with both PWD & Kyle- we are going to need a key FG at least once this season, but it is good to show the cojones every once in a while.
What I would like to see is an improved kickoff coverage team, whether that is a longer kick or more hustle, I don’t care.
by fotodog on Jul 9, 2008 11:35 AM EDT 0 recs
That all well and good until Andy Bailey misses the FG to beat Vandy
I guess that’s where I’m coming from.
We had Coutu last year and had the best redzone record in history.
I think the problem in the old days wasn’t an over confidence and over reliance on Billy Bennett as much as a lack of confidence in Neil Callaway and his cast of one legged, one armed OL from 2003-2006.
In 2003, Billy made 33 or so field goals (the All-Time NCAA record) because Josh Brock and Bartley Miller had 2 working major extremities between them….a rotating Center by committee of awfulness and The Inman and Roland Freshman show at one tackle and Nick Jones as a True Freshman at Guard. The only grown a$$ man on that unit was Big Max, and he was playing the wrong position.
We didn’t kick those FGs because of Billy’s great leg and Richt’s over reliance on him. We kicked them because the OL was more likely to jump off sides or fall down than to pick up 4th and 2.
I agree with the broader point though. Go for it more on 4th down. But I feel that way because Coach Searels is the OMG greatest OL coach on this or any other planet.
by Paulwesterdawg on Jul 9, 2008 5:06 PM EDT 0 recs
Paul, I’d add that we also kicked them in part because Richt tended to be more conservative and rely on the defense. Now, he partly got that way, perhaps, because of some of those same factors you mentioned. And because he couldn’t be that aggressive in 01 (first year, freshman QB, etc), 02 was magical of course (and the only year we averaged over 30ppg in Richt’s tenure as the principal offensive guy), and it was less of an issue.
Richt settled for FGs at times in big games over the years and sometimes it worked out but sometimes it didn’t. But I definately agree that the OL was a factor in this as well, not just in those immediate and borderline calls (e.g. 4 & 2) but in strategy in general, and have been arguing that to certain Maconites for years.
Richt needed to be smarter in his redzone, and really overall, playcalling in general. And yes, he ran the shotgun draw too much (though IMO, people always overstate the overreliance). But out of the I formation (and variants thereof) at various times in PB (Pre Bobo) we were alternately solid to not that great (we certainly had some quality FBs and TBs), and that’s definately an OL thing. It’s too bad injuries claimed Brock and Miller as I think both would have wound up highly regarded by the end of their careers (Brock especially). 04 and 05 might have both been better seasons (and they were both fine seasons for the most part), but them’s the breaks.
May the wings of liberty never lose a feather
by peacedog on
Jul 10, 2008 9:43 AM EDT
up
0 recs









