Dawg Sports: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Backing the Pack for NC State Fans!


spread the word

Completely Unrelated: The Problem with Country Music

What follows has absolutely nothing to do with college football, unless you suppose that Georgia’s upcoming game against Tennessee has me thinking about country music, but this thought occurred to me and simply had to find expression somewhere, so you’re the unlucky ones who get to hear me out on this one.

The problem with country music is that it’s getting too complicated. As what used to be a distinct musical genre in its own right increasingly becomes nothing more than pop music with a twang, country musicians are trying to sound clever and coming across as merely contrived.

I don’t need a country song with a chorus that tells me, "I ain’t as good as I once was, but I’m as good once as I ever was." It’s a country song, not a logic problem; I have neither the time nor the inclination to think through a 17-word sentence in the middle of a song that is supposed to serve as an amusing distraction. I don’t need you to dumb it down, but I do need bullet points.

Even worse than that, though, is the false dichotomy regarding the usage of the word "gone." Although the song has a neat premise and a good line about it being a whiskey night or just a couple of beers, the chorus goes off the tracks when it starts to get down to cases. What, precisely, is supposed to be the difference between "gone for good" and "good and gone," and what differentiates either from "long gone"? For all the song’s effort to make those phrases sound distinguishable, I’m pretty sure that, if your woman says any of them to you in the driveway before getting in her car and leaving, it’s a whiskey night. The song is simply trying too hard.

I understand the irony of this statement coming from me, but brevity is the soul of wit. A good country song gives it to you straight . . . possibly even George Strait. All your rowdy friends are coming over tonight? O.K., I’m with you, Hank; I don’t even need you to explain to me why you drink. I’m pretty sure you’re just carrying on a family tradition. Earl had to die? The Dixie Chicks make out a plausible case for that premise. A left will take her to the interstate but a right will bring her right back here to you? It’s an evocative image, and I have no trouble visualizing the little country store with the old Coke sign way up yonder past the caution light, but the song delivers what it promises: good directions. You’re going to put that boot where? All right, no further details needed, thank you.

Why is Brad Paisley among the most consistent hit-makers in country music? Because he doesn’t get bogged down in complexity. The crux of every Brad Paisley song is a simple declarative statement. "I don’t mind waiting on a woman." "I’m so much cooler online." "I’m still a guy." "I’d like to check you for ticks."

Brad Paisley’s songs work for the same reason such Neil Diamond songs as "Solitary Man" and "Brother Love’s Travelling Salvation Show" work. They’re unvarnished. They’re forthright. Heck, you wouldn’t have any trouble diagramming the chorus of any of them and your middle school English teacher wouldn’t have quibbled too much with the grammar.

It’s a country song. There’s only so hard I’m willing to work while I’m listening to it. Establish the premise, cut to the chase, and don’t try to be deep or (worse) cute. Just tell me you were drunk the day your mama got out of prison and you went to go pick her up in the rain, and we’re good to go.

I now return you to your regularly scheduled sports weblog, which is already in progress.

Go ‘Dawgs!

0 recs | Comment 6 comments | Share on Facebook Digg!

Story-email Email Printer Print

Around SB Nation

Comments

Display:

Country is pretty much dead to me

You hit the nail on the head-its pop music with an accent and a fiddle. Just let me have my copy of At Folsom Prison and leave me in peace. Give me some Gram Parsons (Byrds, Flying Burrito Brothers, or solo) and go away. Keep all that poppy Nashville sheen and shine because all it does is drag a formerly great genre down.If you want something more current, alt-country is the way to go. Drive By Truckers. Uncle Tupelo. That kind of stuff is where its at.

by SG Standard on Oct 8, 2008 7:24 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Not a huge country fan or anything...

but you’re right about At Folsom Prison…I wear that CD out. Yeah, I stil listen to those.

by The ArchDawg on Oct 8, 2008 9:14 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

My problem with country...

…is the “redneckification” of it all. I remember taking a class in college about the constantly changing media perception of the South, and one of the things we often got into heated debates over was the idea of the “good ol’ boy” vs the “redneck,” namely that the good ol’ boy was just your throwback southern gentleman that may get up to no good from time to time but is generally an honest, well meaning guy (thinks the Duke boys and you’ve got it), whereas your rednecks are the trashy, vulgar, often racist folks that just don’t know any better and are to be pitied and avoided. I’m not trying to say that modern country music or the musicians are racist, mind you, but it seems that you can draw a line between the “good ol’ boy” country singers and the “rednecks,” like you can draw the line between seventies rock stars and the ridiculous hair bands of the eighties. The eighties hair bands didn’t see that the older guys were writing great songs and producing incredible music; all they saw were the constant partying and excess and that’s what they wanted and had. Being a “rockstar” was the goal, not creating great music. Same thing with the “redneck” country singers; they think to be authentically “country” they have to sell an image whereas the older guys just went out and made good country music, no matter what their upbringing was. Anyway, since you opened that can of worms…

by Todd on Oct 8, 2008 9:01 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Lyrics

Kyle, I agree with you about the unnecessary complexity of “I ain’t as good as I once was …” One of the things I like about some country songs is use of clever turns of phrase, but they’ve got to be simple: “If I could only put myself in your shoes, I’d walk right back to me”; or even “On the other hand, there’s a golden band”. Somebody tried too hard with that “good as I once was” bit.

I wasn’t exposed to country music growing up, but in the last several years, I’ve developed a serious appreciation for the genre’s music of the ‘60s and ’70s. Give me lines like, "one needs a spankin’ and another needs a huggin’ and one’s on the way" or “We’re not the jet set: we’re the ol’ Chev-ro-let set”.

Having been ignorant of country music most of my life, I’m proud to say that in the past few months I’ve seen both Loretta and Dolly in concert. Both put on great shows.

by NCT on Oct 8, 2008 10:28 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Here's a game

While listening to a country Station, see how many songs fit into this Genre.
Opening Verse about Relationship with Father when you were a child
Chorus
Middle Verse about relationship with child as Father
Bridge
Chorus
Bring it home hard with verse about how your relationship is just like a relationship between the Father and/or the Son, although not usually the Holy Ghost.

Father’s Love by George Straight is the most atypical example of this. A good song, but when compared to all other like songs, begins to fade into the woodwork.

by TexUGAn on Oct 9, 2008 11:36 AM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Yeah, there are an awful lot of songs that take a generic phrase, use it in one context in the first verse, another context in the second, and still another in the third.

We'll carry the banner high!

by TB on Oct 9, 2008 3:21 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.
Start posting about the Bulldogs »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Flowerchucker_small
Quick Question re: Branden Smith
Small
College Football Preview Luncheon
Photo_69_small
Individual/Composite calendars for iCal/Outlook?
Small
College Football Preview Luncheon
Small
muschamp recruits in georgia
Associated_20press_clayliston_1965_l_small
How to Taunt a Georgia Fan
Mtsu_sm_small
Going to UGA
Small
oklahoma state blog
Small
2009 Competition Improves
Small
100 Cocktails

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

Official Partner of CBS Sports