Dawg Sports: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Phillies trade for OF Matt Stairs Bar-right-arrows



NCAA Hijinx Ensnare Vance Cuff

In case you missed it, there's some bad news for the class of 2007. Colquitt County cornerback Vance Cuff has been in a holding pattern the past few weeks because two courses he had been counting on to gain admission were not approved by the NCAA Clearinghouse. One was a computer course and the other a speech communication course.The NCAA changed its rules regarding computer courses this year, disallowing them to meet the core course requirement (athletes enrolling in 2007 must complete 14 core courses).So Cuff went to summer school and replaced that course.

Courses which may be used to meet the requirement are listed on Form 48H, an NCAA document that lists the courses that are considered core courses, on a school-by-school basis.Cuff's high school coach says that when they checked the List of Approved Courses for Colquitt County last week, the computer couse was on it. This week, it was gone, along with Cuff's chance of gaining initial eligibility.

The weird result of Form 48H is that while Introductory Swahili could theoretically be required for graduation from an acreditted high school in Rhode Island, but offered only as an elective in Alabama. Regardless of the difficulty of the respective courses, student athletes taking the course in Rhode Island might well be able to count the course as "core". Even in Cuff's case, had he chosen to go back and take French I as an elective, and passed, he would be qualified.

Speech is a course, of course, of course/But only Myles Brand knows what's core, of course/ And if you don't have enough cores, of course/ you should just take driver's ed. (But not really.That's not a core course at Colquitt County, either.)

This, then is the strange voodoo of the NCAA Clearinghouse. Sometimes the public gets the impression that athletes who do not qualify initially as freshmen are dumb, lazy or both. Unfortunately, they sometimes are just misinformed, as appears to have been the case for Cuff. Because his GPA and test scores are fine, he's not really a candidate for a prep school like Hargrave or Fork Union. Instead, he'll probably have to spend at least one semester at a junior college and report for bowl practice.

The Moultrie Observer has the whole whacked-out story, but in a nutshell, it appears Cuff will be heading to a junior college unless the folks in the Colquitt County school system can pull some serious persuasive jujitsu on the NCAA.

And don't think this is the last time you'll hear from the NCAA on this type of issue. It's a little known fact that the NCAA is actually increasing its core course requirement for initial freshman eligibility to 16 courses for 2008, which will make things even more difficult for some students.

0 recs | Comment 5 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Don't forget. . .
I believe there are some new NCAA regs in place right now.  Like kids can't go to Hargrave anymore just to get a needed credit or two post-graduation.  I might be mistaken on that, but I thought it became the case just recently.  

While that rule makes some sense (it was more aimed at people who simply couldn't graduate and then went off to prep school I suspect), it's just another "FU" in what appears to be an unfortunate situation.  

by peacedog on Jul 10, 2007 1:16 PM EDT   0 recs

Good point peacedog . . .
In fact that's the cruel irony here. If Cuff had slacked off, pulled a 2.0 GPA and a 720 SAT score, he could go to Hargrave for a year, retake the SAT or take the ACT, and get his GPA up.

However, his GPA and standardized test score are high enough, just with the wrong classes. He therefore faces losing a year of eligibility to either a)poor advising or b)fickle NCAA standards. If he had simply coasted through with a C/C- report card, he could go to Hargrave and get bigger, faster and stronger without imperiling his eligibility.

by MaconDawg on Jul 10, 2007 1:59 PM EDT   0 recs

Breaking news?
According to JC Shurbitt with Rivals, you are allowed to make up one course at a prep school under the new rules.  So he could end up there after all.

Otherwise, I agree.  If he's got decent grades (I won't comment on the quality of his course matter as I am not in a position to do so meaningfully; obviously, now all 3.2s are created equal, but I see no reason to make the assumption that he took all crap classes or anything), and the class that got rejected was approved at one point only to become not-approved a few days later.

Bureaucracy in action!

by peacedog on Jul 10, 2007 3:37 PM EDT   0 recs

Not all FUMA guys are academic casualties...
Players go to FUMA for many reasons:
  1. to get better looks if they were under-recruited...like Anthony Constanzo (now at Boston College) who had 4.0 GPA and aced the ACT but didn't attract Div I attention until his year at FUMA.
  2. to gain a year of physical, mental, and football development in a high-speed, focused environment.
  3. to improve study skills, raise SAT scores, and (in a very small number of cases) to raise GPA.
We've produced over 70 NFL players, 2 Heisman Trophy winners (and another finalist), and 10 First Round NFL Draft picks. Our regular high school program has produced stars like Eddie George and Chris Perry, as well as new Georgia recruit Marcus Dowtin.

We're much more than a repair facility for academic casualties.

Fork Union Military Academy - Success stories begin here.

by CaptDan on Jul 11, 2007 9:03 AM EDT   0 recs

Good point CaptDan . . .
That's eerily similar to what I said a few days ago about Marcus Dowtin:

"http://www.dawgsports.com/story/2007/7/2/122120/9528"

I know there have been several student athletes from Georgia who were just not physically developed who went to prep school just to fill out a little.

I would add that I think the prep school experience is good for helping some young men develop emotional maturity. For some it is their first extended time away from family, and it helps to be in a supportive, but disciplined, environment.

by MaconDawg on Jul 11, 2007 10:55 AM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Images_small
Behold Uga VII!
Avatar_small
Fantasy Football (Public and Private), Pickem Leagues, Confidence pools, etc... Good site
Will_queen_photo_small
On Fathers, Sons, and College Football
Small
What's the Deal?
Millers_crossing
Mayor, you may have lost your title
Millers_crossing
Which of these teams will reemerge as national contenders?
100_0141_small
Marcus Howard is loved in the pro's
Small
Georgia bar in LA???
36413436t_small
ASU Tix in Hand; You East Coasters Will Have them Today or Tomorrow
Uga_small
Sturdivant Injured?  NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

ad

Site Meter