Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Jerry Sandusky's Wife Tries To Run A Reporter Over

Giving Credit Where Credit Is Due

The blogosphere is in an uproar.  Here is what went down:  

Yost at The M Zone posted his own version of the infamous Wonderlic test about three weeks ago.  

Later, E.S.P.N. Radio's Colin Cowherd quoted Yost's posting verbatim on the air without giving proper credit to the source of his material.  

When this was brought to Cowherd's attention, his response was:  "WE HAD NO IDEA..BUT THE INCESSANT WHINING...MEANS I WON'T GIVE YOU CREDIT NOW..GET OVER IT."  Apparently, the E.S.P.N. Radio host is unfamiliar with the maxim that, if you write an e-mail with the caps lock on, that's an e-mail you don't need to send.  

Regrettably, video did not, in fact, kill the radio star.  

Yost is outraged and he isn't the only one.  Here is what I wrote to George Solomon, E.S.P.N.'s ombudsman:  

Dear Mr. Solomon:  

I hope this message finds you doing well.  I am writing, as many have before me, to express my concern over Colin Cowherd's recent actions, both on the air and off.  

As you are aware, Mr. Cowherd recently read extensive excerpts of a lengthy posting from a weblog known as "The M Zone," for which he failed to cite the source.  This, I believe, was an honest mistake on his part; it appears that the posting came to him through a message board and he simply did not know at the time that he read it that it needed proper attribution.  

Certainly, this was a forgivable error which was easily correctable.  All Mr. Cowherd needed to do was make mention of the actual source on a subsequent broadcast and the problem would have been solved.  No lengthy apology was required, but simply an acknowledgment and correction of the oversight.  

Where Mr. Cowherd crossed the line was in his insolent and condescending response to an e-mail from the authors of The M Zone, who bought this lapse to his attention.  While those webloggers might have stated their case more graciously in the first instance, nothing in their e-mail to Mr. Cowherd warranted anything like the flippant, dismissive, and disrespectful response they received.  

E.S.P.N. did not become "The Worldwide Leader in Sports" by conducting its business in this manner.  Mr. Cowherd's recent actions display a slipshod approach to verifying sources, an undignified disdain for the audience without which he would be out of a job, a remarkable failure of good judgment, and a degree of carelessness and crassness that is so unbecoming as to cast the entire E.S.P.N. family of networks in an exceedingly unfavorable light.  

Mr. Cowherd should admit his error, both in his casual approach to providing proper on-air attribution to the actual authors of his material and, much more seriously, in his arrogant harangue against someone he genuinely had slighted.  Mr. Cowherd's utter lack of professionalism in this entire sorry episode reflects poorly on him and, if his employer does not take appropriate steps to admonish him, it will reflect poorly on E.S.P.N., as well.  

I trust the legitimate complaints of the many sports fans who have contacted you recently will not go unheeded.  No one is calling for Colin Cowherd's head to roll, but a modicum of journalistic integrity and the most rudimentary demonstration of good manners are not too much to ask of a man who is, for many thousands of listeners, the daily voice of your network.  

I hope I may look forward to the news of Mr. Cowherd's on-air apology to The M Zone, to sports fans in general, and to E.S.P.N. viewers and listeners forthwith.  E.S.P.N.'s action (or inaction) in this instance will speak volumes about the Worldwide Leader's respect for its audience and its concern for good customer relations.  I trust your reaction will not be a Cowherdly one.  

I thank you for your time and attention to this matter.  

Sincerely yours,
T. Kyle King
www.dawgsports.com


Your support for The M Zone would be appreciated.  

Go 'Dawgs!  

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

good letter
I happened to be lsitening to this on my sirius radio when he read off these on the air. He mentioned it coming from the internet, but it was never as you could tell in fact this was true as he set up the bit as being a wunderlick test he found on the internet.

I happened to be cracking up hearing these and it was my impression that these bits were his own.

For a guy who blasts bloggers all the time, its time for him to make the clarification of the source to his listeners.

by swampy on Mar 24, 2006 7:10 AM EST reply actions  

honestly, i feel for the Mzone, but
But cowherd probably didn't know who wrote it. it probably was just emailed to him.

that said, he could've not been a peckerhead about it in his response.

by Paulwesterdawg on Mar 24, 2006 6:14 PM EST reply actions  

You're right . . . on both points
I agree, twice.  

Because other bloggers have had the strength of character to come forward and own up to their accidental transgressions, the chain of events seems pretty clear:  The M Zone wrote and posted it; someone cut and pasted it to a message board with no more attribution than "I found this and I thought it was funny"; someone else (I believe his handle is "Six Degrees of Bowden" or suchlike) picked it up from there, attributing it only to "a message board"; Colin Cowherd's intern or whoever got it from Six Degrees.  

While I think taking two minutes to Google it isn't too much to ask of the Worldwide Leader in Sports, there was no deliberate attempt to pilfer material and no genuine indiscretion in saying, "I got this off of the internet," since, after all, he did and no source was cited.  

The offensive part of all this is Cowherd's reaction.  The M Zone took a bit of a snide tone with him when they wrote Cowherd, but their irritation was understandable and nothing The M Zone had to say warranted anything like the infantile all-caps dissing they received from Cowherd, who flagellated them for their so-called incessant whining (bear in mind how brief the turnaround time was between his broadcast and the author's e-mail; there hadn't yet been time for cessation) and used that as a justification for failing to give proper attribution to his source even after his oversight was pointed out to him.  

That's not the logic of a responsible human being and it certainly isn't the tone or attitude of a professional.  I don't think the guy ought to be fired or anything, but an on-air apology for refusing to cite sources out of pure spite and being so disrespectfully dismissive of those he legitimately, if unintentionally, had wronged doesn't seem too out of line.  

All the dude had to do was say, "My bad.  I'll mention y'all on the air tomorrow."  That would have solved the whole problem and it is the sort of thing even the lowliest, most poorly run local newspaper would have done.  

The problem wasn't the error, which was understandable and forgivable.  The problem was the refusal to right the wrong and the fact that the refusal was based not on principle, but on holier-than-thou arrogance.  

by T Kyle King on Mar 24, 2006 8:47 PM EST up reply actions  

Looks like
M Zone just got their apology. Good for Colin to be man enough to admit it. Wasn't really sure where he was going with that "To Kill a Mockingbird" thing though. Making fun of himself I suppose.

by JP @ Dawg Sports on Mar 27, 2006 12:54 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation community devoted to the Georgia Bulldogs.

Managers

Beard_47_series_wins_and_42_points_in_2007_small T Kyle King

017oa_small MaconDawg

Editors

Redstage_small DavetheDawg

Whistling_past_small NCT

434477_small vineyarddawg

Layfield_logo_small RedCrake

Hey-why-so-serious_small tankertoad

Podunkdawg_as_a_child_small podunkdawg

Dawggone_small Ludakit

Authors

28488_443996218101_804558101_5903592_3665419_n_small Spears

Small hailtogeorgia

Killface_small Mr. Sanchez

50questions-accountant_small The Quincy Carter of Accountants